When something stopped working years ago, the first question was usually:
লেখক Anjan N Ghosh··46K বার পড়া
Whatever Happened to Repairing Things?
When something stopped working years ago, the first question was usually:
“Can this be repaired?”
These days I suspect many of us ask a slightly different question:
“What should I replace it with?”
I include myself in this. If an old gadget develops a problem, one part of my brain wants to find out what’s wrong with it. Another part has already opened Google and is watching reviews of the latest model.
Repair never stood much of a chance.
Things Used to Come Apart
Many older electronic products were relatively straightforward to open. Batteries could be removed. Screws were visible. Individual components could often be replaced without dismantling half the device.
Modern gadgets are very different.
Our phones are incredibly thin. Smartwatches survive swimming pools. Earbuds contain batteries, microphones, speakers, sensors and wireless electronics inside something barely larger than a grape. Achieving that requires manufacturers to pack everything together incredibly tightly.
That’s wonderful until something breaks.
The same construction that gives us slim bodies and water resistance can also make devices difficult and expensive to repair. Sometimes a tiny failed component doesn’t mean replacing a tiny component. It means replacing an entire assembly.
And that’s when the calculator comes out.
Welcome to Repair Mathematics
Suppose a gadget costs ₹20,000 new and repairing the old one costs ₹8,000.
Now the internal negotiations begin.
“₹8,000 is quite a lot.”
“The new model is faster.”
“It has better battery life.”
“And technically I’m saving ₹8,000 by spending another ₹12,000.”
This is the sort of mathematics that should probably not be shown to an accountant.
Sometimes replacement genuinely makes more sense. But other times the problem is simply an ageing battery.
Rechargeable batteries don’t last forever. Their ability to hold charge gradually reduces as they chemically age. (Apple Support) A perfectly usable phone can therefore begin feeling old simply because it no longer survives the day.
Replace the battery and suddenly the supposedly obsolete phone may have plenty of useful life left. Battery replacement is, for example, a normal service option offered for iPhones rather than automatically requiring replacement of the device. (Apple Support)
Earbuds Make This Even Stranger
Wireless earbuds are a particularly interesting example.
They’re wonderful little pieces of technology, but they contain extremely small rechargeable batteries. When those batteries eventually deteriorate, the rest of the electronics may still work perfectly well.
You can end up replacing an entire sophisticated electronic product because one tiny battery has reached retirement age.
That’s a very different relationship with technology from the one many of us grew up with.
Repair Is Slowly Becoming Part of the Conversation Again
There is at least some movement in the other direction.
India now has an official Right to Repair portal covering sectors including mobile and electronic devices, consumer durables, automobiles and farming equipment. It provides information such as warranties, spare parts and authorised service options, with the broader aim of helping consumers keep products usable for longer.
I’m not suggesting we should all start opening smartphones on the dining table with a screwdriver.
I certainly won’t.
But perhaps we’ve become slightly too comfortable treating electronics as disposable.
Before replacing something, there are three questions worth asking: Can it be repaired? How much will that cost? And how much useful life will the repair give me?
If a ₹5,000 repair gives a good gadget another two years, that’s worth considering. If the repair costs almost as much as replacement and other parts are already ageing, perhaps it isn’t.
And yes, there is also the e-waste problem. Every gadget we unnecessarily replace eventually becomes something somebody has to deal with. Keeping useful electronics working a little longer isn’t just good for the wallet; it can also reduce that waste.
I should probably remember all this the next time one of my gadgets develops a fault.
First investigate the problem. Then check the repair cost. Then make a sensible decision.
And only after that start watching reviews of the new model.