AI Can Generate A Work, But Can It Be The Author? What India’s Copyright Office Says
Artificial intelligence can now write stories, generate images and create videos. But when an AI system produces something original, a more difficult question follows: who is legally its author, and who owns the copyrigh
लेखक Karishma Jain··48K पढ़े गए
AI Can Generate A Work, But Can It Be The Author? What India’s Copyright Office Says
Artificial intelligence can now write stories, generate images and create videos. But when an AI system produces something original, a more difficult question follows: who is legally its author, and who owns the copyright?
India’s Copyright Office has now addressed that question in an order involving DABUS, an artificial intelligence system created by US inventor Stephen L Thaler.
In its August 31 order, the Copyright Office found that an artwork generated through DABUS, titled A Recent Entrance to Paradise, met the originality requirement under Indian copyright law.
But it refused to recognise DABUS itself as the author.
What Was The DABUS Case About?
Thaler filed the copyright application on May 3, 2022. He described A Recent Entrance to Paradise as an artistic work first published in the United States in 2016.
In the application, DABUS — short for Device for the Autonomous Bootstrapping of Unified Sentience — was named as the author, while Thaler claimed copyright ownership.
Thaler’s case was that DABUS had carried out the central generative process behind the image. His representatives said the AI system produced the artwork autonomously through neural-network processes including training, association formation, perturbation, monitoring, stabilisation and output generation.
Thaler, meanwhile, had designed, configured and trained the system.
That left the Copyright Office with two separate questions: whether the artwork itself was original, and whether DABUS could legally be recognised as its author.
Why Did The Artwork Pass The Originality Test?
Section 13 of the Copyright Act provides protection for “original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works”. But the Act does not define the word “original”.
According to Business Standard, the Registrar therefore relied on the standard developed through Indian copyright jurisprudence, including the Supreme Court’s ruling in Eastern Book Company v. D.B. Modak.
Under that standard, a work does not need to be completely novel or inventive to qualify for copyright. It must have a minimum degree of creativity and must be independently created rather than copied from an existing work.
In the case of A Recent Entrance to Paradise, the Registrar examined the arrangement of visual forms, colours, tonal variations, spatial relationships and other compositional elements. The material placed before the Copyright Office did not show that the final composition reproduced any identified earlier work.
The order therefore made a clear distinction between originality and authorship.
“Section 13 examines whether the resulting work possesses independently generated, non-trivial expressive character; Section 2(d)(vi) separately identifies the legally recognised person to whom authorship of that work is attributed,” the order said.
The Registrar concluded: “The work accordingly satisfies the requirement of originality under Section 13 of the Copyright Act, 1957.” The finding, however, was limited to the particular work and material before the Registrar.
If DABUS Generated The Image, Why Was It Not The Author?
This is where Section 2(d)(vi) of the Copyright Act becomes important.
For a computer-generated literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work, the provision identifies the author as “the person who causes the work to be created”.
Thaler maintained that DABUS had performed the core generative process.
The Copyright Office, however, found that Thaler had conceived and created DABUS, configured its operation, supplied the visual inputs, curated the linguistic inputs, provided descriptions connecting the material and initiated the process that produced the artwork.
On those facts, the Registrar held that Thaler was the “person who caused this particular work to be created”.
The order also distinguished between a system generating an output and the person to whom the law attributes authorship.
“The fact that a system operates autonomously after being configured does not alter the identity of the person responsible for bringing the work into existence. Autonomy in execution is not synonymous with conception of a work,” the Copyright Office said.
Why Can’t An AI System Be Recognised As An Author?
The Copyright Office found that DABUS had no statutory recognition, civil personality or independent legal capacity.
In other words, the AI system was not a person recognised by law.
Recognising DABUS as an author would therefore require treating an AI system as a new category of legal or juristic person — something the Registrar said could not be done through administrative interpretation of the existing Copyright Act.
“DABUS cannot be entered as author under Section 2(d)(vi),” the order said.
The Copyright Office also made clear that whether AI should someday be granted legal personhood or authorship is a question for Parliament.
“Whether legal personhood or authorship should ever be extended to autonomous artificial intelligence remains a policy decision strictly reserved for Parliament, and cannot be introduced via administrative reinterpretation,” the office said.
This is not the first time an AI system has appeared as an author in an Indian copyright application.
According to Business Standard, an AI-generated painting called Suryast, created using the RAGHAV Artificial Intelligence Painting App, was initially registered with lawyer and artist Ankit Sahni and RAGHAV listed as co-authors.
The Copyright Office later issued a withdrawal notice in November 2021 seeking information about RAGHAV’s legal status and referring to provisions dealing with authorship.