Why India's 7.8% GDP Growth Number Holds Up Amid The Debate
India’s economy grew at a robust 7.8% in real terms in the April-June quarter, delivering a stronger-than-expected start to FY27 and providing fresh evidence that domestic economic activity remains resilient despite a ch
مصنف Mohammad Haris··25K بار پڑھا
Why India's 7.8% GDP Growth Number Holds Up Amid The Debate
India’s economy grew at a robust 7.8% in real terms in the April-June quarter, delivering a stronger-than-expected start to FY27 and providing fresh evidence that domestic economic activity remains resilient despite a challenging global environment.
The latest GDP print has, however, triggered a debate over the way the numbers are calculated, particularly after the release of the new GDP series with 2022-23 as the base year. Critics have questioned the sharp revision in the previous year’s nominal GDP and argued that the latest growth rate may look stronger because of the change in the statistical series.
But the argument does not take away from the underlying strength visible in the latest data. Economists defending the number, including SBI Group Chief Economic Adviser Soumya Kanti Ghosh, have pointed out that the 7.8% growth is supported by a broad set of economic indicators and that the most widely cited alternative calculation of 2.6% is based on comparing two different GDP series.
SBI Research, in its latest Ecowrap, has also strongly backed the official estimate, calling the debate the result of an “incorrect data interpretation”. It said India grew 7.8% year-on-year at constant prices and 10.3% at current prices in Q1 FY27.
Growth not driven by a single sector or component
One of the strongest arguments in favour of the latest GDP print is that growth was not driven by a single sector or component. Real gross value added (GVA) grew 8.2% during the quarter, indicating that the underlying production-side momentum was also strong. The latest data showed healthy activity across manufacturing and services, while investment and consumption remained supportive.
Ghosh, in his Indian Express article, points to a range of indicators that reinforce the GDP picture. GST collections, domestic passenger vehicle sales, tractor sales, industrial production, steel and cement output, as well as exports, all showed signs of economic activity remaining firm during the quarter.
The point is important because GDP estimates are ultimately an aggregation of activity across the economy. When the headline growth rate is accompanied by strength across several independent indicators, it becomes harder to dismiss the number as merely a statistical outcome.
The SBI Ecowrap similarly argues that the reported Q1 FY27 growth “does not stand alone” and cites the performance of GVA, GST collections, domestic passenger vehicle sales, tractor sales, industrial production, steel and cement, as well as exports, as signs of an economy expanding at a healthy pace.
The 2.6% number: what is the debate and what are the arguments
The controversy largely began with former Finance Secretary Subhash Chandra Garg questioning the sharp revision in the previous year’s nominal GDP.
Garg has argued that the Q1 FY26 current-price GDP figure originally released under the old 2011-12-base series was around Rs 86 lakh crore. The corresponding figure under the new series is now around Rs 80 lakh crore. Using the older figure as the comparison point, he argues that nominal growth would have been much lower and has questioned whether the 7.8% real growth figure adequately represents economic activity.
That argument has been taken up by opposition leaders and has turned the GDP release into a political controversy.
However, this is not the same as an alternative calculation of real GDP growth using the official methodology.
MoSPI has pointed out that the Rs 86.05 lakh crore figure cited by critics belongs to the old GDP series, whose base year was 2011-12. The new GDP series, introduced in February 2026, uses 2022-23 as the base year. Under that series, Q1 FY26 current-price GDP was initially estimated at Rs 80.32 lakh crore and was subsequently revised as additional data and updated price indices became available.
Ghosh, in his article, also said, “Last year, when the NSO had released the first quarter FY26 GDP numbers (base: 2011-12), the nominal GDP for the quarter was Rs 86.1 lakh crore. In the latest release (base: 2022-23), the Q1 FY26 GDP number has been revised downwards to Rs 80 lakh crore. Alongside, the latest Q1 FY27 GDP number is at Rs 88.3 lakh crore.”
He added that some are now ascribing a 2.6 per cent growth in nominal GDP for the latest quarter instead of 10.3 per cent by calculating the yearly growth rate using Rs 88.3 lakh crore (we call it series A for the sake of clarity) over Rs 86.1 lakh crore (we call it series C). This is a sign of intellectual dishonesty.
“If anyone truly wants to compare current nominal GDP numbers over the previous unrevised base of the first quarter of last year, then Rs 88.3 lakh crore (new base, series A released in August) should be estimated over Rs 80.4 lakh crore (new base, released in June), which comes out to Rs 9.7 per cent growth (as against 10.3 per cent),” he said.
Hypothetically, even with this nominal growth (by adjusting the deflator), the real growth for Q1 FY27 would be 7.4 per cent (as against the released 7.8 per cent), still good enough in view of the exogenous challenges during the quarter. Comparisons need to be made on the same base, using the same method, Garg wrote.
He added that the 2.6 per cent number being touted is neither the official real growth rate nor a like-for-like comparison. It is a hybrid comparison between a current-year level of the new series and an old-series previous-year level. That may make for a dramatic talking point, but it does not provide meaningful growth rate for a reality check.