Who Checks Your Food? Maharashtra FDA Challenges FSSAI's Inspection Powers In High Court
Maharashtra’s Food and Drugs Administration (FDA) has moved the Bombay High Court against the Centre and the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), alleging an illegal “parallel system” that takes over the
Ni Sumedha Kirti··120K nabasa
Who Checks Your Food? Maharashtra FDA Challenges FSSAI's Inspection Powers In High Court
Maharashtra’s Food and Drugs Administration (FDA) has moved the Bombay High Court against the Centre and the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), alleging an illegal “parallel system” that takes over the state’s power to inspect food businesses. The court will hear the case next on November 26.
The petition, filed by the State of Maharashtra through its Commissioner of Food Safety, came up on Friday before a bench of Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna.
At its core is a simple question: who gets to check whether the food served at big restaurants, hotels and manufacturing units is safe, the state or the Centre? The FDA says the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 gave that job to the states, and that the FSSAI has gradually taken it over.
What Is Maharashtra Asking The Court To Do?
The state has sought three things: that the court strike down the central regulations it calls contentious, stay an FSSAI circular dated May 12, 2023, and direct the FSSAI to hand all registration records on its online portal, the Food Safety Compliance System (FoSCoS), back to state officers.
Why Does FDA Say The FSSAI Has Overstepped?
According to the petition, Parliament meant the 2006 law to spread food safety work across states. Under it, the State Food Safety Commissioner and local authorities inspect eateries, grant manufacturing licences and prosecute errant businesses.
The FDA alleges that the FSSAI’s Chief Executive Officer used his powers to create posts such as “Central Licensing Authority” and “Central Food Safety Officer”, which the Act does not provide for.
The state argues the CEO’s role is limited to framing food safety standards and clearing imported food at entry ports, not routine inspections in local neighbourhoods.
What Is May 2023 Circular?
The FDA calls it a key point of dispute. According to the petition, the circular stopped state officers from inspecting or acting against businesses that hold a Central Licence. The state says this weakened its ability to monitor food safety on the ground and wants it stayed immediately.
Why Is FoSCoS Portal In Dispute?
The petition alleges the portal was deliberately set up to bring as many food businesses as possible under central licensing, which the state says widened the FSSAI’s reach at the cost of the system the 2006 law intended.
What Do FDA Officials Say Happens In Practice?
Senior FDA officials said they want to reclaim the state’s right to inspect every food business as it sees fit.
At present, they said, businesses with a turnover of Rs 50 crore or more fall under the Central Licensing Authority. This means the state FDA needs prior written permission from the FSSAI each time it wants to inspect such businesses or 3-star hotels.
One official said the only recent exception was the inspection of Park Inn by Radisson in Navi Mumbai, whose food licence the FDA suspended.
“At that time, we had a complaint, based on which the FDA commissioner (Tukaram Mundhe) allowed us to move forward,” the official said. In other cases, the official added, “we had to seek permission or have FSSAI officers accompany us”.
What The FDA Has Raised In Its Petition
Issue
What Maharashtra FDA alleges
What it wants
Who should enforce the law
The 2006 Act gave inspections, licensing and prosecution to the state commissioner and local authorities
Enforcement restored to the state
Central posts
The FSSAI CEO created ‘Central Licensing Authority’, ‘Central Food Safety Officer’ and central analyst posts that the Act does not provide for
Central regulations and amendments struck down
CEO’s powers
Limited to framing standards and clearing imports at entry ports, not routine inspections
Court to define the limits
May 12, 2023 circular
Restricts state officers from inspecting or acting against Central Licence holders
Immediate stay
FoSCoS portal
Configured to bring as many businesses as possible under central licensing
All registration records transferred back to state officers