Votes Polled Vs Votes Counted: EC Pushes Back Against Report Flagging Discrepancies In 51 Seats
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has rejected a report alleging discrepancies between the number of votes polled and the number counted in 51 constituencies across Maharashtra, Haryana and Jammu and Kashmir during
Ni Niraj Kumar··121K nabasa
Votes Polled Vs Votes Counted: EC Pushes Back Against Report Flagging Discrepancies In 51 Seats
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has rejected a report alleging discrepancies between the number of votes polled and the number counted in 51 constituencies across Maharashtra, Haryana and Jammu and Kashmir during the 2024 Lok Sabha and assembly elections.
The report, published by The Reporters’ Collective, had claimed that in several constituencies, the number of votes counted through Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) did not match the total number of votes polled. It alleges that in some seats, fewer votes were counted than those polled, while in others, the number of votes counted exceeded the votes polled.
Claiming to have based its findings on internal Election Commission records, the report raised questions over the accuracy of vote-counting data in the three states. However, the specific internal documents referred to in the report have not yet been made public. The publication has indicated that it intends to release these documents at a later stage.
On Wednesday, the Chief Electoral Officers (CEOs) of Maharashtra and Haryana issued fact-checks rejecting the allegations, describing the report as false, factually incorrect and misleading. The commission argued that the discrepancies highlighted in the report stem from an incorrect interpretation of publicly available electoral data.
CLAIM OF FEWER VOTES COUNTED THAN POLLED
The report alleged that in 12 constituencies, the number of votes counted through EVMs was lower than the total number of votes polled.
Among the constituencies cited are Badkhal in Haryana, Mumbai North in Maharashtra, Beed Lok Sabha constituency, Dahanu assembly constituency in Maharashtra and Tosham assembly constituency in Haryana.
In the case of Badkhal, the report claims that approximately 3.32 lakh votes were polled, while only around 1.60 lakh votes were counted.
However, the Election Commission has disputed the interpretation of these figures. Its fact-check maintains that the report has presented the total number of registered voters as the number of votes actually polled in several constituencies, including Badkhal.
The commission reiterated that no complaints regarding discrepancies in Form 17C were received from the constituencies in question after polling. Form 17C is the statutory account of votes recorded at each polling station. Its copies are provided to polling agents of candidates at the conclusion of polling, enabling them to verify the number of votes recorded.
CLAIM OF MORE VOTES COUNTED THAN POLLED
The report has also alleged that in 20 constituencies, the number of votes counted was higher than the number of votes polled. These include Kaithal assembly constituency in Haryana, Pulwama, Kokernag and Chenani assembly constituencies in Jammu and Kashmir, as well as the Srinagar Lok Sabha constituency.
In the case of Kaithal, the report claims that 1,67,070 more votes were counted than the number of votes polled.
The Haryana Chief Electoral Officer’s office has rejected the allegation, citing official Election Commission data available in the public domain. According to the CEO’s fact-check, a total of 1,68,851 voters cast their votes in Kaithal. The office has described the claim of 1,67,070 additional votes being counted as misleading.
MUMBAI NORTH: EC SAYS TOTAL ELECTORATE MISTAKEN FOR VOTES POLLED
Mumbai North Lok Sabha constituency is another key example cited in the report. It alleges that 7,78,674 fewer votes were counted than those polled.
The Election Commission has rejected this claim, stating that the report has confused the total number of registered voters with the actual number of votes cast.
According to official ECI data, Mumbai North had approximately 18.11 lakh registered voters. However, the actual number of votes polled in the 2024 Lok Sabha election was 10,36,496. The commission argues that the report has treated the total electorate as the number of votes polled and used the difference between the two figures to suggest that 7,78,674 votes were not counted.
The EC has termed this interpretation factually incorrect and misleading.
ZERO ENTRIES IN POLLING STATION RECORDS
The Reporters’ Collective had also raised questions over entries in polling station records, alleging that at several locations, the number of voters was not recorded and election officials entered zero in documents where voter figures were supposed to be mentioned.
The report has cited internal Election Commission records to support its allegations. However, the Maharashtra and Haryana CEO offices have challenged the methodology and interpretation used to arrive at the conclusions.
The commission maintains that the figures cited in the report are available in its publicly accessible records dating back to 2024.
At the heart of the controversy is the interpretation of electoral data, particularly the distinction between the total number of registered voters, votes actually polled and votes counted. While The Reporters’ Collective has alleged discrepancies across 51 constituencies, the Election Commission has rejected the findings, maintaining that the report has drawn misleading conclusions by comparing different categories of electoral data.