‘Sitting In AC Office… How Dare You?’: Gujarat HC Raps Collector Over Affidavit Remarks Against Judge
The Gujarat High Court has expressed strong displeasure with Vadodara Collector Anil Dhameliya over remarks he made about a judicial officer in an affidavit, rejecting his repeated apologies and warning that he had “cros
Ni Shuddhanta Patra··54K nabasa
‘Sitting In AC Office… How Dare You?’: Gujarat HC Raps Collector Over Affidavit Remarks Against Judge
The Gujarat High Court has expressed strong displeasure with Vadodara Collector Anil Dhameliya over remarks he made about a judicial officer in an affidavit, rejecting his repeated apologies and warning that he had “crossed the limits”.
Justice Niral R Mehta criticised the Collector’s conduct during the hearing and questioned why he had included comments about a judicial officer in his sworn statement. The court also took note of separate pending contempt proceedings against Dhameliya and asked the state administration to examine his conduct before it considers initiating contempt proceedings in the present matter.
“Are you performing your duty in accordance with the dictum of the court? You don’t follow any law? Sitting in your AC office and you are alleging against a judicial officer? How dare you?” Justice Mehta told Dhameliya during the hearing.
Court objects to remarks in affidavit
The court was examining an affidavit filed by Dhameliya in response to a query concerning the rejection of an application seeking permission for non-agricultural (NA) use of certain land.
The Collector had rejected the application on August 17, 2026, mainly because revision applications were pending before the Gujarat Revenue Tribunal (GRT). However, the petitioner claimed that the proceedings had concluded in 2024.
In his affidavit, Dhameliya referred to an order passed by the then in-charge chairman of the GRT concerning other land in Anand district. He stated that the chairman had passed the order “without properly appreciating and interpreting the orders passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat”.
In its order, the High Court said the Collector could have simply explained that the disposal of the revision applications was not reflected on the online portal, rather than including additional details about the tribunal chairman.
“The collector Vadodara could have in short stated that the disposal of the aforesaid revisions were not reflected in the online portal. However, he chosen to narrate the history, which prima facie, according to this court, is nothing but imputing aspersion against a judicial officer. Such facts on oath being completely irrelevant is not only disturbing, but scandalous in nature,” Justice Mehta observed.
The judge repeatedly asked Dhameliya why he had included those details and refused to accept his unconditional apology. The Collector also offered to withdraw the affidavit, but the court declined to allow it.
“Many of dozens of dozens of orders. I have been ignoring you. But you cross the limit now,” Justice Mehta said.
Court questions sincerity of apologies
The court also considered pending contempt proceedings against Dhameliya in a separate case, in which a Division Bench framed charges in April 2026. Justice Mehta expressed concern that similar issues were continuing despite those proceedings.
Questioning whether repeated apologies could be considered genuine when such conduct appeared to recur, the judge asked: “What is the measure and gauge of sincerity? How can I gauge? What is the measurement of it? Please tell me if you have any kind of equation for that, a barometer of that. How would I gauge that your particular officer is sincere enough giving apology? It would mean that in future it would not be repeated.”
When Dhameliya apologised again, Justice Mehta remarked that he could offer such apologies to his superiors instead.
The judge also said the court maintained restraint and decorum while dealing with government officials, even when it disagreed with their decisions.
“We find all your orders rubbish. Have I said anything against you? Because we restrain, we follow decorum. You should not forget this,” he said.
State asked to examine Collector’s conduct
The High Court subsequently asked T Natarajan, Additional Chief Secretary in charge of the General Administration Department (GAD), to join the proceedings virtually and explain what action the state administration proposed to take against Dhameliya.
Justice Mehta told Natarajan that repeated apologies were not enough to address concerns about the Collector’s conduct.
“We never say anything against any officer, but your officer should not even think to venture about this. He has crossed the limits. He is not immune. He must know that,” the judge said.
Natarajan assured the court that the administration would take its observations seriously and requested that the Collector’s apology be considered.
However, the court clarified that it was not directing the administration to take any specific action. It ordered that the relevant case papers, including Dhameliya’s affidavit and details of the pending contempt proceedings, be placed before the Additional Chief Secretary for independent consideration.
The GAD has been given an opportunity to examine the Collector’s conduct and inform the court of the action it proposes to take before the High Court considers whether to initiate contempt proceedings.