ICC prosecutors cite 'fabricated' PNP drug war accounts in testimony bid
PRAGUE Czech Republic – International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutors have asked the Trial Chamber III to admit another set of prior recorded testimonies of witnesses against former President Rodrigo Duterte – this time
Ni ANDY PEÑAFUERTE III,JAY-VEE MARASIGAN PANGAN··172K nabasa
ICC prosecutors cite 'fabricated' PNP drug war accounts in testimony bid
PRAGUE Czech Republic – International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutors have asked the Trial Chamber III to admit another set of prior recorded testimonies of witnesses against former President Rodrigo Duterte – this time from those who can provide proof of the alleged pattern of crimes in his administration’s war on drugs.
In their sixth request, released publicly on November 2, Acting Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang said that admitting the prior recorded testimonies of witnesses P-1136, P-1345, P-1391, and P-1404 would cut direct examination time from 16 hours to four hours.
As with previous applications, the prosecution seeks to apply ICC Rules of Procedure and Evidence Rule 68(3) for this batch of witnesses.
If Trial Chamber III approves, the court would admit this batch of witnesses' prior recorded statements, alongside their court appearance for “focused supplementary questioning”. They would also remain available for cross-examination by Duterte’s defense.
Prior recorded testimonies of four witnesses
The prosecution stated that P-1136, P-1345, P-1391, and P-1404 provide evidence on violence in the Philippines before and during Duterte’s presidency, including the targeting of alleged drug personalities, the use of watchlists, and alleged efforts to conceal or justify killings.
The prosecution also said the four accounts establish a policy to “neutralise” alleged criminals through violent crimes, including murder, as well as the alleged widespread and systematic character of crimes committed during the drug war.
P-1136’s statement indicates that Duterte allegedly targeted public officials considered “high-value targets” over suspected involvement in illegal drugs, with some allegedly appearing on the so-called “PRRD List”. Prosecutors said the testimony goes to their allegation that Duterte had a policy to “neutralise” local officials allegedly linked to the illegal drug trade.
For P-1345, the prosecutors said the statement is evidence of a “new pattern of killings during ‘One Time Big Time’ operations” in Manila after Duterte became president. The witness discussed nine case files involving PNP killings of alleged drug personalities and identified an alleged pattern that included planting shabu and guns near victims’ bodies. The witness also said journalists, human rights groups, labor leaders and judges who opposed the Duterte administration were “red-tagged” as drug personalities or communists.
P-1391’s evidence, the prosecutors stated, is on the use of drug watchlists, patterns of “fabricated Philippine National Police (PNP) accounts of killings,” the alleged use of paid assets by police to carry out killings, and rewards allegedly received by PNP officers as incentives. The witness also provides evidence relating to Incidents 21 and 30 in the prosecution’s case.
The prosecution also said P-1404’s testimony is evidence of barangay clearance operations and different types of drug watchlists, including PDEA, barangay, PNP, and presidential lists. Prosecutors said the witness described how barangay captains were allegedly ordered through the Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) to submit updated watchlists every month. P-1404 also provides evidence on the aftermath of the killing of Kian delos Santos, identified as Incident 30, and on reports in which killings were presented as “accomplishments.”
Pending decision
If the Chamber grants the application, prosecutors are asking for around one hour of supplementary examination for each witness instead of an estimated four hours of direct examination per witness.
This would save “at least 12 hours of court time,” the prosecutors argued, adding that such testimonies would not prejudice Duterte because the defense would still have “ample opportunity to cross-examine” all four witnesses.
P-1136, P-1345, P-1391, and P-1404 would also be asked at the start of their testimony whether they consent to having their earlier statements introduced into the trial record.
The filing comes a day after Trial Chamber III held a status conference as the ICC enters the final weeks of preparations for Duterte’s trial.
Duterte is facing three counts of crimes against humanity involving murder and attempted murder allegedly committed during his terms as Davao City mayor and Philippine president.
His trial is scheduled to open on November 30 before Trial Chamber III, composed of Presiding Judge Joanna Korner and Judges Keebong Paek and Nicolas Guillou.
Three more witnesses on Davao Death Squad
A separate prosecution filing released publicly on November 3 turns back to Davao City and the alleged roots of Duterte’s anti-drug campaign, with three witnesses – P-0009 P-1032 and P-1409 – expected to testify on the Davao Death Squad (DDS), the targeting of alleged criminals and Duterte’s alleged role in the killings.
Prosecutors said the three witnesses provide evidence on the targeting of alleged criminals in Davao City during Duterte’s years as mayor and on the alleged policy to “neutralise” suspected criminals through violent crimes, including murder.
The testimonies, prosecutors said, are relevant to the alleged attack in Davao City, while those of P-0019 and P-1409 provide evidence that goes to Duterte’s alleged individual criminal responsibility, including his knowledge and intent.
P-0019’s testimony covers alleged extrajudicial killings in Davao City, their alleged patterns and widespread nature, and what prosecutors described as an atmosphere of fear and impunity. The witness also described Duterte naming alleged criminals on his television program Gikan sa Masa, Para sa Masa, with some of those individuals subsequently killed.
P-1032, meanwhile, provides evidence on the alleged existence and composition of the DDS, its targeting of alleged criminals and the atmosphere in Davao City at the time. The witness also discusses Laud Quarry and its alleged use by the DDS as a gravesite. According to the filing, P-1032 was once warned that there was an order for the witness to be killed and later fled to another part of the Philippines.
P-1409’s testimony concerns alleged DDS extrajudicial killings and accounts that prosecutors say are consistent regarding killings allegedly carried out pursuant to Duterte’s orders. Prosecutors also said the witness provides evidence on alleged financial rewards for killings provided by Duterte to DDS handlers through co-perpetrator Sonny Buenaventura. They said the testimony goes to Duterte’s alleged responsibility for ordering killings and providing financial incentives to perpetrators.
Prosecutors say the three accounts help establish both the alleged DDS operation in Davao and Duterte’s individual criminal responsibility during his mayoral years.
The prosecution is asking that the prior recorded testimonies be admitted under Rule 68(3), which would cut their combined direct examination from nine hours to three. All three witnesses would still appear before the Chamber and remain available for cross-examination.
Opposition
Last week, Duterte’s defense team opposed the prosecution’s request to admit the previously recorded testimonies of two witnesses at the International Criminal Court (ICC) without requiring them to testify in court.
In a document dated October 26, the defense asked the ICC Trial Chamber III to reject the prosecution’s application to admit the prior recorded testimonies of witnesses identified as P-1393 and P-1416.
“It submits, however, that P-1393 and P-1416 should be heard viva voce or, alternatively, pursuant to Rule 68(3), given the centrality of their evidence and the need for cross-examination,” the defense said.
“The admission of associated materials must likewise remain subject to the Chamber’s strict criteria and cannot extend to evidence that witnesses have neither meaningfully addressed nor explained in their prior recorded testimony,” it added.—LDF GMA News