‘Such A Disappointing Interaction’: Lawyer’s Courtroom Dress Draws Debate After Judge Calls It ‘Inappropriate’
A Texas criminal defence lawyer says a judge questioned her choice of dress during a short court hearing, asking her to approach the bench and explaining that she considered the outfit unsuitable for court.
مصنف Buzz Staff··83K بار پڑھا
‘Such A Disappointing Interaction’: Lawyer’s Courtroom Dress Draws Debate After Judge Calls It ‘Inappropriate’
A Texas criminal defence lawyer says a judge questioned her choice of dress during a short court hearing, asking her to approach the bench and explaining that she considered the outfit unsuitable for court.
Mariah Medina, a San Antonio-based lawyer and former TV news journalist, shared the incident after appearing at the Bexar County Government building. She also posted a picture of the dress she was wearing that day.
Lawyer Says Judge Questioned Her Dress
Medina said the judge, Yolanda Huff, who has served on the bench since 2019, asked her to come closer after noticing her outfit. The lawyer said she was surprised because she had worn the same dress while working on television and at other courts.
“This is what I was wearing today when a judge said that I was inappropriately dressed for court,” she wrote. “It’s a dress I’ve worn on air countless times and a dress that I have worn to other courts without issue. I was confused, so I explained that it’s a shift dress,” Medina added.
According to the New York Post, Medina said Huff laughed and asked whether she really thought the dress was suitable for a jury trial. The judge also asked whether she had a blazer in her car.
“She laughed and asked if I really believed that my dress was appropriate for a jury trial… then asked me if I had a blazer in my car,” she wrote. “Such a disappointing interaction and a first since licensure,” Medina added.
Medina Says She Would Follow The Court’s Dress Rules
Medina later told the New York Post that the judge referred to her outfit as a “tank top”, while she maintained that it was a shift dress. She said the dress cost about $30 from J. Crew and that she considered it suitable for business wear.
“She has a list of things that she forbids in court re: attire, but this is not on that list. I grew up in a conservative church and I was truly confused. It’s appropriate length, doesn’t expose cleavage… it’s a J Crew dress for crying out loud, not a Hoochies Anonymous Club,” Medina said.
She also said she would cover her shoulders in Huff’s courtroom if asked. “I respect the authority of the court. And I will wear a blazer to cover up [if asked],” she said.
This is what I was wearing today when a judge said that I was inappropriately dressed for court.
It’s a dress I’ve worn on air countless times and a dress that I have worn to other courts without issue.
I was confused, so I explained that it’s a shift dress… pic.twitter.com/PUIeyOKGFS
— Mariah Medina (@MMedinanews) September 21, 2026
Social Media Users Disagree Over Courtroom Dress
The incident led to different views online. Some users said the dress was suitable, while others argued that courtroom clothing should follow more formal standards.
“Retired lawyer. 42 years. Over 100 jury trials in state and federal courts. Dozens of oral arguments in state appellate courts and the 9th Circuit. The dress is fine. The judge was being petty. Publicly shaming you was way out of line,” one user wrote.
“I think ppl are confusing inappropriate with the judge just didn’t like what you were wearing, even the judge. She could have pulled you to side and told you she wanted you to wear sleeves in your next court appearance rather than trying to publicly humiliate you & label your,” commented another.
Others took the opposite view. “It’s a sleeveless dress, and men also have to cover their shoulders. I do not see sex discrimination in asking all legal professionals to cover their shoulders. Courts are serious places. The priority is the people whose lives may be affected,” one user wrote.
“If a judge says it’s inappropriate to wear in their courtroom. It’s inappropriate end of discussion,” said another.
Disclaimer: This article is based on user-generated content. The claims made in the original post have not been independently verified by News18.