'What Does Your Father Do?': Bengaluru Recruiter Refuses To Proceed With Job Seeker's Interview After He Declines To Answer
A job seeker’s interview reportedly took an unexpected turn after a recruiter allegedly refused to proceed with the hiring process when he declined to reveal his father’s occupation.
By Buzz Staff··39K reads
'What Does Your Father Do?': Bengaluru Recruiter Refuses To Proceed With Job Seeker's Interview After He Declines To Answer
A job seeker’s interview reportedly took an unexpected turn after a recruiter allegedly refused to proceed with the hiring process when he declined to reveal his father’s occupation.
The candidate questioned why his family background was relevant to a Data Analyst role, sparking a debate on Reddit over the kind of personal questions recruiters should be allowed to ask during job interviews.
Sharing his experience on Reddit’s r/TechInterviewsIndia, the user described how what initially appeared to be a routine recruitment conversation took an unexpected turn when the recruiter asked him about his family background.
The post, titled, “Recruiter ended my interview because I refused to disclose my father’s occupation. Is this normal in India?”, detailed the candidate’s interaction with the HR representative.
According to the user, he had received an email a few days earlier about a Data Analyst opening in Bengaluru. Although he did not remember applying for the position, he decided to attend the screening call. He also mentioned having 3.5 years of experience in Data Engineering and a Master’s degree in Computer Science from the US.
The interview reportedly began with conventional questions about his education, professional experience and career background. However, the conversation took an unexpected turn when the recruiter asked him to share details about his family.
When the candidate sought clarification, the recruiter specifically asked, “What does your father do?” Surprised by the question, he reportedly asked her, “How is my father’s occupation relevant to this position?”
The recruiter allegedly explained that asking about family backgrounds was part of the company’s standard screening protocol and that she was required to collect the information. She also reportedly told him that he was free not to answer if he was uncomfortable sharing such details.
The candidate subsequently declined to discuss his family’s personal information. However, he claimed that the recruiter then told him, “Okay, then I can’t proceed further with the interview. I need that information to move ahead.”
The response left him confused, particularly because the recruiter had initially indicated that answering the question was optional. He further claimed that she said she would consult her supervisor regarding his refusal and get back to him.
Candidate Raises Questions About Recruitment Process
Apart from the unusual interview experience, the Reddit user also highlighted several aspects of the recruitment process that he found questionable. He claimed he could not recall applying for the position and had no application confirmation. Additionally, he was unable to locate the advertised vacancy on the company’s official careers page or LinkedIn profile.
He also pointed out that the recruitment email had been sent through a third-party form service, while its reply-to domain was different from the company’s primary website. The candidate added that he could not independently verify whether the recruiter was genuinely associated with the organisation.
However, he clarified that he was not outright claiming the recruitment process was fraudulent, acknowledging that some Indian companies do ask candidates personal questions during HR screenings.
What he found difficult to understand was why his father’s profession should influence his suitability for a Data Analyst position. He maintained that he had no objection to discussing his education, professional experience, technical skills, salary expectations, relocation preferences or availability, as these were directly relevant to the job.
Questioning whether asking about parents’ occupations was still common in corporate interviews in India, he sought opinions from other users on whether he was right to challenge the recruiter or had overreacted.
Reddit Users React
The incident prompted several Reddit users to weigh in, with many questioning the relevance of such personal questions during recruitment.
One user strongly criticised the alleged practice, writing, “It is NOT a standard procedure. It looked like a way to collect data for social engineering scams later on. Like accident scam etc. PS : I am surprised! People in the comments here are so darn stupid!!!!”
“Yesterday I got the same question in the HR round (cleared technical and manager round) and I told them casually dad does this, mom does this, brother does this. She vaguely asked why I didn’t go in that field, and I told her it takes a long time to settle in that field etc. I didn’t think too much of it. But I find it strange that she rejected you specifically for not disclosing this. Maybe they find it easier to coerce you into a lower salary if you come from a poor background,” another user commented.
“This is normal in any responsible country in the world. If your father is a govt employee, there are extra checks that needs to be done. I remember the joining date for one of my friend to an american bank was delayed by 3 months because his dad was a high up govt employee,” a third comment read.
Recruiter ended my interview because I refused to disclose my father’s occupation. Is this normal in India?
by
u/Harshada2503 in
TechInterviewsIndia
Meanwhile, some users advised job seekers to be cautious when interviewers ask questions unrelated to their professional qualifications. One Redditor remarked, “If in interview, be it HR or technical, they ask you about family background, just run away. They are looking for people whom they can exploit.”
Another user described the recruiter’s alleged response as suspicious and recommended seeking clarification directly from the organisation. “This is VERY suspicous behaviour. Its best to follow up with org nd ask about their policies in this regard. Especially written policies. If not you can file a legitimate complaint against the person Also, i think u dodged a bullet here..he he,” the user wrote.
Sharing a similar sentiment, another Redditor said they had never encountered such questions during multiple interviews, adding, “Not normal. I have sat for multiple interviews never been asked this. Only time I was asked when I was being scammed.”
Disclaimer: This article is based on user-generated content. The claims made in the original post have not been independently verified by News18.