UP MLC Polls: BJP's Reality Check On Candidates, Cadre And Local Connect Ahead Of 2027 Battle
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Thursday won six of the 11 Uttar Pradesh Legislative Council seats contested in the graduate and teacher constituencies, while the Samajwadi Party (SP) secured five, gaining ground in
By Oliver Fredrick··61K reads
UP MLC Polls: BJP's Reality Check On Candidates, Cadre And Local Connect Ahead Of 2027 Battle
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Thursday won six of the 11 Uttar Pradesh Legislative Council seats contested in the graduate and teacher constituencies, while the Samajwadi Party (SP) secured five, gaining ground in key constituencies ahead of the 2027 assembly elections.
The BJP retained the same number of seats it had won in the 2020 elections, while the SP increased its tally from three to five. The results were marked by SP victories in the Lucknow Graduates’ constituency and both Varanasi constituencies, besides the party’s wins in Agra Teachers’ and Allahabad-Jhansi Graduates’.
The BJP won the Meerut Graduates’, Agra Graduates’, Lucknow Teachers’, Meerut-Saharanpur Teachers’, Bareilly-Moradabad Teachers’ and Gorakhpur-Faizabad Teachers’ constituencies. The SP won the Allahabad-Jhansi Graduates’, Lucknow Graduates’, Varanasi Graduates’, Varanasi Teachers’ and Agra Teachers’ seats. No independent candidate won any of the 11 constituencies.
The outcome gives the SP an opportunity to highlight its gains before the assembly elections, while the BJP will have to assess why it could not improve on its previous tally despite campaigning across the constituencies.
The SP’s victory in the Lucknow Graduates’ constituency was one of the most significant setbacks for the BJP. SP candidate Kanti Singh defeated BJP’s Avanish Kumar Singh to wrest the seat from the ruling party.
In Varanasi, represented by Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the Lok Sabha, the SP won both the Graduates’ and Teachers’ constituencies. Ashutosh Sinha won the Graduates’ seat, while Lal Bihari Yadav retained the Teachers’ constituency.
The results give the SP a political talking point in a region closely associated with the prime minister. However, graduate and teacher constituencies have a restricted electorate, and the results cannot be directly equated with voting trends in general elections.
The SP also won the Agra Teachers’ constituency, where Akash Agrawal defeated BJP nominee Hari Kishore Tiwari. Agrawal had previously won the seat as an independent before joining the BJP and subsequently contesting on an SP ticket.
In the Allahabad-Jhansi Graduates’ constituency, SP candidate Man Singh Yadav retained the seat, defeating BJP candidate Ashok Kumar Rathore by 27,663 votes.
The BJP’s performance was supported by victories across several teacher constituencies and in the Meerut and Agra graduate seats.
In the Meerut Graduates’ constituency, BJP candidate Dinesh Kumar Goyal won, while Manvendra Pratap Singh retained the Agra Graduates’ seat. The party also retained the Lucknow Teachers’, Meerut-Saharanpur Teachers’ and Bareilly-Moradabad Teachers’ constituencies. In Gorakhpur-Faizabad Teachers’, BJP candidate Dhruv Kumar Tripathi retained his seat, securing 16,790 votes. The contest had drawn attention during counting amid allegations of irregularities by the opposition.
The BJP’s tally is unchanged from 2020, when the party won six seats, the SP three and independent candidates two. This time, the contest between the two major parties accounted for all 11 victories.
Reflecting on the results, deputy chief minister Keshav Prasad Maurya acknowledged that the BJP had expected to win more seats. “These elections are decided by highly educated and qualified voters. The BJP has repeated its previous performance, but we expected to win more seats. We will examine why we fell short,” Maurya said.
He also said the party would review why the Opposition had won constituencies where the BJP expected a favourable outcome.
UP’s political pundits said the results have put the spotlight on candidate selection, local networks and constituency-level campaigning.
Elections to graduate and teacher constituencies differ from assembly polls because the electorate is limited to registered voters in specific categories, making candidates’ personal standing and local organisational support particularly important.
Political analyst Dr Shashikant Pandey, head of the department of political science at Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar University, Lucknow, said: “In graduate and teacher constituencies, the personal credibility of a candidate, local networks and constituency-level issues can play a decisive role. A party’s broader popularity does not automatically translate into votes in these elections.”
The BJP’s unchanged tally means the results do not represent a wholesale shift in the balance of power in the Legislative Council constituencies. However, the SP’s increase from three seats to five, coupled with its victories in Lucknow and Varanasi, gives the opposition party an opportunity to claim momentum ahead of the Assembly elections, said Pandey.
The results, he said, also highlighted the importance of constituency-specific factors. While the SP made gains in some closely watched seats, the BJP retained six constituencies, including the Gorakhpur-Faizabad Teachers’ seat.
Both parties are likely to examine the outcome as they prepare for the 2027 assembly polls. For the BJP, the immediate challenge is to assess its losses despite retaining its overall tally. For the SP, the task will be to determine whether its gains in these restricted-electorate contests can translate into a broader political advantage.