'Taking Us For A Ride': Delhi HC Gives 3 Weeks To Kejriwal, Sisodia To Respond To Criminal Contempt Case
The Delhi High Court on Tuesday pulled up Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leaders Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia, Sanjay Singh and others over their failure to file responses in a criminal contempt case initiated over alleged rem
By Vani Mehrotra··88K reads
'Taking Us For A Ride': Delhi HC Gives 3 Weeks To Kejriwal, Sisodia To Respond To Criminal Contempt Case
The Delhi High Court on Tuesday pulled up Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leaders Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia, Sanjay Singh and others over their failure to file responses in a criminal contempt case initiated over alleged remarks and social media posts targeting Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma.
Refusing to grant any further extension, the court gave the leaders a final opportunity of three weeks to submit their replies, warning that their right to respond would be closed if they failed to meet the deadline.
A bench of Justices Navin Chawla and Arun Bhardwaj expressed displeasure over the repeated delay, making it clear that the opportunity being granted was the last one.
“Three weeks. Last opportunity. Otherwise, we are closing (right to file) replies,” the bench told the lawyers appearing for the alleged contemnors.
The court’s sharp observations came after counsel for one of the respondents submitted that the complete case records had not yet been received in accordance with an earlier direction.
Rejecting the submission, the bench said the registry had confirmed that the relevant records had already been provided to the alleged contemnors.
“We have a report from the registry that full compliance has been done. This is not done. We will not give further time. You are taking us for a ride. You will file the reply in three weeks. Otherwise, we will close the right,” the bench remarked.
The matter has been listed for further hearing on January 14.
WHAT IS THE CRIMINAL CONTEMPT CASE AGAINST KEJRIWAL, SISODIA?
The criminal contempt proceedings were initiated suo motu on May 14 by Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma against Kejriwal, Sisodia, Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Singh and other AAP leaders, including Durgesh Pathak, Saurabh Bharadwaj and Vinay Mishra.
The proceedings relate to alleged remarks and social media posts targeting the judge in connection with the Delhi excise policy case.
Justice Sharma had taken exception to posts allegedly attributing political allegiance and affiliation to her and questioning her impartiality.
In her order initiating the proceedings, Justice Sharma had alleged that Kejriwal orchestrated a “calculated campaign of vilification” against her on social media instead of pursuing legal remedies.
The judge had also expressed concern over the circulation of an allegedly misleading edited video of a speech she delivered at an educational institution in Varanasi. She had further taken note of clips from court proceedings in the excise policy matter being circulated on social media.
According to the contempt order, the circulation of such material was creating a “parallel narrative” around the judicial proceedings. Justice Sharma had also observed that remaining silent in the face of the alleged campaign would not amount to judicial restraint.
HIGH COURT HAD ISSUED NOTICES IN MAY
On May 19, the Delhi High Court issued notices to Kejriwal and the other proposed contemnors in the suo motu proceedings and granted them four weeks to file their responses.
Senior advocate Rajdipa Behura was appointed as amicus curiae to assist the court in the matter.
During an earlier hearing, Kejriwal’s counsel had argued that the complete material forming the basis of the contempt proceedings had not been supplied. The court had directed the registry to provide the remaining records to the respondents.
At Tuesday’s hearing, however, the bench relied on the registry’s report confirming that the relevant records had been supplied and declined to grant another extension.
The court also asked AAP leaders, including former MLA Gopal Rai, and journalist Saurav Das to file their responses to a separate petition seeking criminal contempt action against them for allegedly participating in an “orchestrated social media campaign” against Justice Sharma.
WHY DID KEJRIWAL AND SISODIA SEEK JUSTICE SHARMA’S RECUSAL?
The contempt proceedings are linked to the developments surrounding the Delhi excise policy case.
On February 27, a trial court discharged Kejriwal, Sisodia and 21 others in the case, holding that the prosecution’s case was unable to withstand judicial scrutiny and stood discredited in its entirety.
The CBI challenged the discharge order before the Delhi High Court, where Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma was hearing the matter.
Kejriwal, Sisodia and other AAP leaders subsequently moved applications seeking the judge’s recusal from hearing the CBI’s challenge. However, Justice Sharma dismissed their pleas on April 20.
Following the rejection of their applications, Kejriwal, Sisodia and Durgesh Pathak wrote to the judge stating that they would not appear before her, either personally or through a lawyer. They also said they would follow the path of “Satyagraha” advocated by Mahatma Gandhi.
In her subsequent contempt order, Justice Sharma clarified that the CBI’s challenge to the discharge of the accused persons would be heard by another bench.