‘Confidence In Election Process Vital’: SC Defers Andhra Poll Panel’s Final List Till Oct 25
The Supreme Court on Wednesday directed the Andhra Pradesh State Election Commission (APSEC) to defer publication of the final list of candidates for civic polls until October 25, observing that confidence in the elector
By News Desk··81K reads
‘Confidence In Election Process Vital’: SC Defers Andhra Poll Panel’s Final List Till Oct 25
The Supreme Court on Wednesday directed the Andhra Pradesh State Election Commission (APSEC) to defer publication of the final list of candidates for civic polls until October 25, observing that confidence in the electoral process is essential to constitutional democracy.
A vacation bench comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana was hearing a plea filed by the Yuvajana Sramika Rythu Congress Party (YSRCP), which alleged that violence and threats prevented its candidates from filing nomination papers for the upcoming elections.
The court asked the state election commission to examine complaints from the YSRCP and other candidates, along with relevant evidence that they were prevented from submitting nominations. It directed the commission to decide by Thursday whether the nomination deadline should be extended.
The bench also instructed the state Director General of Police (DGP) to ensure adequate security for contesting candidates and election offices, noting that the filing of nomination papers is an essential component of free and fair elections.
Clarifying the scope of its intervention, the court said it was not directly interfering in the election process but was permitting the SEC to examine the party’s grievances and take an appropriate decision.
SC Says YSRCP Has Made Out Prima Facie Case
The bench observed that although constitutional courts generally refrain from interfering in elections, they can intervene when necessary to prevent unconstitutional or illegal actions from undermining the fairness of the process.
“Instilling confidence in the election process is vital for the maintenance of constitutional democracy. While the constitutional courts would not ordinarily interfere with the election process, their hands are not tied when appropriate interference is necessary to ensure that free and fair elections are not polluted by unconstitutional or illegal means,” it said.
The top court said the YSRCP, led by YS Jagan Mohan Reddy, had “made out prima facie case” that several of its candidates were prevented from filing nomination papers for elections to around 100 urban local bodies.
“Bearing in mind these principles and the materials placed before us, which include various representations made by the petitioner-party as well as the candidates before the SEC both physically and in electronic form, as well as electronic evidence in the form of video clippings, etc., we think that the petitioner has made out a prima facie case for passing the directions,” the bench recorded in its order.
The court asked the APSEC to take all necessary measures to address apprehensions among the YSRCP and other candidates regarding the conduct of free and fair elections in the state.
It also directed the commission to submit a compliance affidavit by October 27, when the matter will be heard next.
SC Says Nomination Filing Is Part Of Free And Fair Elections
The bench reiterated that the right to contest elections by filing nomination papers forms an integral part of the free and fair electoral process.
“Free and fair election is a basic structure of the Constitution. The right to participate in such elections by filing nominations is a facet of the free and fair election process.
“While it is the constitutional mandate to vest the state election commission with the duty of conducting and supervising such elections, which would necessarily include all steps to ensure free and transparent filing of nomination papers by the contesting candidates, the power of the constitutional courts to exercise judicial review in furtherance of the election process cannot be said to be wholly nugatory,” it said.
The court acknowledged that the State Election Commission has constitutional authority over the conduct and supervision of elections and that judicial intervention must ordinarily be limited.
“Such philosophy of deference has grown from a doctrine of necessity that the election process must be entrusted in the hands of an independent constitutional authority and within a timeline, and not be mired in the quagmire of judicial interference,” the bench said.
However, it added that constitutional courts remain responsible for protecting constitutional values and cannot entirely refrain from judicial review when a principal opposition party presents relevant material raising serious concerns about obstruction during nomination filing.
The bench further observed that if law and order issues threaten the fairness and impartiality of elections, courts must uphold constitutional principles.
YSRCP Alleges Candidates Were Prevented From Filing Nominations
The YSRCP claimed that candidates of the ruling party were likely to be elected unopposed in around 19 urban local bodies because opposition candidates were allegedly prevented from filing their nomination papers amid violence and obstruction.
The petition sought police protection for candidates, an extension of the nomination deadline and the designation of additional or alternative nomination centres to allow candidates to submit their papers safely.
According to the plea filed by party general secretary Lella Appireddy, several YSRCP candidates were allegedly assaulted and physically stopped from reaching nomination centres during the nomination period, which ran from October 16 to October 18.
Senior advocate Maninder Singh and advocate Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki represented the YSRCP, while senior advocate Siddharth Luthra appeared for the state government and opposed the plea.
The party had earlier approached the Andhra Pradesh High Court seeking an extension of the nomination deadline. However, the High Court dismissed its application, holding that the deadline had expired and that extending it would amount to interference with the election process.