Noel Tata Calls N Chandrasekaran Re-Appointment Vote ‘Illegal’
The Tata Sons board on September 17 voted 4-1 in favour of N Chandrasekaran continuing at the helm of the group holding company, people familiar with the proceedings told Moneycontrol, reopening a succession question tha
By Deborshi Chaki··15K reads
Noel Tata Calls N Chandrasekaran Re-Appointment Vote ‘Illegal’
The Tata Sons board on September 17 voted 4-1 in favour of N Chandrasekaran continuing at the helm of the group holding company, people familiar with the proceedings told Moneycontrol, reopening a succession question that appeared settled only weeks ago.
Noel Tata told Moneycontrol that he considered the vote “illegal”, challenging the validity of a decision that could have significant implications for the leadership of India’s largest business group.
“I voted against Chandra’s appointment as chairman. My veto was wrongfully overridden on the basis of a legal opinion. The decision is illegal. I recorded my dissent,” Tata told Moneycontrol in a brief interview in the evening.
According to people familiar with the matter, the Tata Trusts, headed by Noel, would move to oust Chandra at the Annual General Meeting (AGM). “Once he is ousted as a director he cannot continue as chairman,” said a person familiar with the matter.
“The AGM will be held the moment the SRTT issues is resolved,” the person said.
“One of the Tata Trusts had already voted to begin the succession process and accept Chandra earlier decision not to seek a third term,” said a person familiar with the matter.
Emails sent to Tata Sons and Tata Trusts remained unanswered at the time of publication of this story.
At the centre of the the dispute is an article in Tata Sons Articles Association which says a majority of directors appointed by Tata Trusts on the Tata Sons board have to approve any consequential decision.
The executive management of Tata Sons seems to have proceeded on the basis of a legal opinion which said the chairman of the board meeting has casting vote in case of a deadlock.
The board comprises Chandrasekaran, Noel Tata, Venu Srinivasan, Saurabh Agrawal, Harish Manwani and Anita Marangoly George.
Thursday’s vote marks a sharp turn from August, when Chandrasekaran decided not to seek another term after his tenure ends on February 20, 2027.Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT), one of the two principal Tata Trusts, subsequently said it respected Chandrasekaran’s decision and initiated the process of constituting a selection committee to recommend the next Tata Sons chairman.
AGM Takes Centre Stage
Attention will now shift to Tata Sons’ adjourned annual general meeting, which is required to be held by December 31.
The AGM assumes significance because Chandrasekaran is due to retire by rotation as a director of Tata Sons and his reappointment will require shareholder approval.
That could give Tata Trusts, which collectively owns about 66 percent of Tata Sons, a crucial role in determining what happens next.
The two principal trusts — SDTT and Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) — together hold a majority of Tata Sons. Their position on Chandrasekaran’s reappointment as a director will, therefore, be important when the matter comes before shareholders.
There is, however, another complication.
SRTT is restrained from convening trustee meetings following proceedings before the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner. The restriction has already affected decision-making connected with Tata Sons.
Tata Sons’ AGM, originally scheduled for August 18, had to be adjourned after SDTT and SRTT could not jointly nominate the representative required for the meeting.
Unless the issue surrounding SRTT is resolved before the reconvened AGM, the restriction could once again complicate the Trusts’ ability to take decisions relating to Tata Sons.
That makes the AGM the next important stage in a leadership question that has moved rapidly over the past month — from Chandrasekaran deciding to leave, to the Trust beginning the search for his successor and now to a Tata Sons board majority backing his continuation.
RBI changes equation
The September 17 vote also comes against the backdrop of another challenge for Tata Sons — the prospect of a public listing.
The Reserve Bank of India recently rejected Tata Sons’ request to surrender its registration as a Core Investment Company, according to people familiar with the matter. The move has brought the listing requirement applicable to upper-layer non-banking financial companies back into focus.
Tata Sons had sought deregistration after becoming debt-free. With that route now blocked, the holding company has to determine its response to the RBI decision.
People familiar with discussions at Tata Sons had earlier told Moneycontrol that some directors believed continuity at the top could become important if the company has to navigate the regulatory, shareholder and corporate complexities of a potential listing.
A Tata Sons listing would be unlike a conventional IPO. The holding company owns substantial stakes in some of India’s largest listed companies, including Tata Consultancy Services, Tata Motors and Tata Steel, while also controlling major unlisted businesses such as Air India.
Chandrasekaran, who has chaired Tata Sons since 2017, has overseen some of the group’s biggest strategic moves, including the Air India acquisition and large investments in new businesses.
The board vote indicates that four directors who participated in Thursday’s decision want that leadership continuity.
But the 4-1 verdict does not necessarily settle the matter. Noel Tata’s opposition, his challenge to the validity of the vote, the succession process already initiated by SDTT and Chandrasekaran’s impending reappointment as a director at the AGM mean the leadership question could now move from the Tata Sons boardroom to its shareholders.