Lawmakers, advocacy groups condemn 'Machong Chismisan' hosts over remarks on Josh Aquino
Lawmakers and advocacy groups — aside from personalities and celebrities — have condemned the hosts of the “Machong Chismisan” podcast over their remarks about Josh Aquino, the eldest son of actress Kris Aquino, calling
By JADE VERONIQUE YAP, GMA News··15K reads
Lawmakers, advocacy groups condemn 'Machong Chismisan' hosts over remarks on Josh Aquino
Lawmakers and advocacy groups — aside from personalities and celebrities — have condemned the hosts of the “Machong Chismisan” podcast over their remarks about Josh Aquino, the eldest son of actress Kris Aquino, calling for respect and accountability in discussions involving persons with disabilities (PWDs).
ML Partylist Rep. Leila de Lima
ML Partylist Representative Leila de Lima was among those who spoke out against the incident, questioning why making fun of persons with disabilities had become a subject of entertainment.
“Are they proud of making fun of persons with disabilities? Do they think that kind of conversation is worthwhile?” De Lima said in Filipino in a statement posted on social media.
She said the incident reflected a lack of understanding, compassion, and respect for others, particularly at a time when awareness, acceptance, and inclusion of persons with disabilities should be actively promoted.
"It is truly saddening and infuriating that instead of working together to promote awareness, acceptance, and inclusion, some people still make autism the subject of jokes," she said.
De Lima described the remarks as disrespectful, insensitive, and unacceptable, emphasizing that the situation became even more concerning when the podcast episode was aired and made available for a wider audience.
"“Even thinking about it is already wrong. Saying it to make people laugh makes it even worse. Continuing to air it so that more people can watch and hear it is absolutely wrong.”
She also called for those involved to be held accountable for their words and actions.
“Having a disability is not a joke. The struggles, sacrifices, and challenges faced by families of persons with disabilities are certainly not something to laugh about," she added.
Senator Risa Hontiveros
Senator Risa Hontiveros also condemned the remarks in a statement dated October 15, emphasizing that persons with disabilities should never be mocked, belittled, or demeaned.
“It is never acceptable to mock, belittle, or demean persons with disability. They are not a punchline, and their lives should not be fodder for ridicule, whether on air, online, or in private conversation,” Hontiveros said.
She stressed that Philippine laws uphold the dignity of persons with disabilities and prohibit discrimination against them.
“Our laws clearly uphold the dignity of every Filipino with a disability," she said in Filipino.
Hontiveros also cited the National Autism Care, Support, and Inclusion Act, which she is advocating, as part of efforts to strengthen protections and promote inclusion for persons with disabilities.
Addressing the public, particularly individuals with large platforms, the senator said a person's character is reflected in how they treat society's most vulnerable members.
“To everyone, especially those with platforms: remember that the true measure of our character is how we treat the most vulnerable members of our society. They are the ones we should protect, not make fun of.”
Department of Social Welfare and Development
The Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) also weighed in on the controversy, reminding content creators that they have a responsibility to protect the dignity, privacy, and rights of persons with disabilities.
In a statement on Wednesday, October 14, DSWD spokesperson Assistant Secretary Irene Dumlao said the agency was reacting to the podcast episode, which drew criticism for making fun of persons with disabilities, particularly those on the autism spectrum.
“Every individual with a disability, including those on the autism spectrum or with neurodevelopmental conditions, deserves dignity, respect, privacy, and the utmost care,” Dumlao said.
“Exploiting a person's disability for amusement, ridicule, or online engagement is unacceptable, as it reinforces harmful stereotypes and drives discrimination against a vulnerable group,” she added.
The agency urged content creators to exercise responsibility when discussing issues involving vulnerable sectors, whether their disabilities are apparent or non-apparent.
Dumlao stressed that protecting the dignity of persons with disabilities is not merely an act of compassion but also part of upholding their human rights.
The DSWD also reminded the public that Republic Act No. 7277, or the Magna Carta for Persons with Disabilities, as amended by Republic Act No. 9442, prohibits acts that shame, ridicule, or vilify persons with disabilities in public or online spaces.
Under the amended law, such acts may be punishable by law.
The agency further called on content creators to refrain from making persons with disabilities, including individuals experiencing psychosocial crises or other vulnerable circumstances, the subjects of ridicule or insensitive discussions.
“Content creators, like their counterparts in mainstream media, bear the responsibility of fostering respectful and inclusive digital spaces, ensuring that all content always observe sensitivity and mindfulness on the rights of vulnerable individuals,” Dumlao said.
The DSWD confirmed that the podcast content had already been taken down and that the hosts had issued a public apology.
Rep. Ann Matibag
House Committee on Women and Gender Equality chairperson Rep. Ann Matibag also condemned the podcast hosts, describing their remarks about Josh as an example of cruelty rather than comedy.
In a statement, Matibag cited the episode's title and the derogatory remarks directed at Josh, including calling him “walang kwenta” and “nakatunganga.”
She said it was disturbing that adults would turn a person's disability into a source of amusement, particularly when the person being discussed may not be in a position to defend himself against the public ridicule.
“As a mother, I am deeply angered by the public ridicule directed at Josh Aquino, a person with disability. As a children's rights advocate and a woman leader, I find it appalling that grown men would turn someone's disability into entertainment,” Matibag said.
“There is nothing funny, brave, or masculine about mocking someone who may not be in a position to defend himself. That is not humor. That is cruelty,” she added.
Matibag also highlighted the responsibility of society to treat people with dignity regardless of their abilities or differences.
She rejected what she described as a culture of toxic masculinity that mistakes humiliation for strength and cruelty for humor, emphasizing that true strength lies in defending vulnerable individuals rather than ridiculing them.
“Our laws, particularly RA 7277 as amended by RA 9442, expressly prohibit public ridicule and vilification of persons with disabilities. Calling it a joke does not erase responsibility or accountability,” she said.
Matibag expressed solidarity with Josh, his mother Kris, and other families advocating for the protection and dignity of their loved ones.
She stressed that the controversy was not simply about one podcast episode or an offensive remark but also about society's willingness to tolerate discrimination against persons with disabilities.
“We cannot speak of inclusion and equality while tolerating the humiliation of persons with disabilities,” she said.
“Disability is never a punchline. Cruelty is never comedy. And silence in the face of discrimination is never acceptable,” she added.
Autism Society Philippines
The Autism Society Philippines reminded content creators that publicly ridiculing persons with disabilities is unacceptable, emphasizing that “disability is not a punchline.”
The organization also cited Republic Act No. 7277, or the Magna Carta for Disabled Persons.
“As a community, we must not give our precious time to watching creators and listening to podcasts not capable of basic respect,” the statement read.
“Freedom of expression must never come at the expense of the rights and humanity of persons with disabilities."
Akbayan Partylist Rep. Perci Cendaña
Akbayan Party-list Rep. Perci Cendaña likewise criticized the remarks, emphasizing that a person's disability should never be used to measure their worth.
Cendaña said calling Josh or any other person with a disability “walang silbi” was unacceptable and violated the dignity and respect every individual deserves.
“It is infuriating that, to this day, a person's disability is still being used as a measure of their worth,” Cendaña said in Filipino.
“It is wrong to call Josh or any person with a disability 'useless.' Aside from being against the law, it is a clear violation of the dignity and respect that we all deserve.”
Cendaña also rejected the notion that discrimination could be justified as humor, declaring: “Discrimination doesn't make anyone macho. It's disgusting.”
National Council on Disability Affairs
The National Council on Disability Affairs (NCDA), meanwhile, called on content creators and influencers to exercise sensitivity, respect, and responsibility across digital platforms.
“Humor that crosses the line and stomps on one's dignity is not comedy; it is blatant discrimination,” the NCDA said.
The council described the now-deleted podcast segment as an example of malicious mockery and demeaning commentary directed at persons with disabilities, particularly those on the autism spectrum.
It warned that humor targeting vulnerable individuals under the guise of freedom of expression could reinforce harmful stigma and discrimination.
The NCDA also emphasized that the responsibility to promote respectful online spaces extends beyond content creators. It urged social media users to refrain from sharing, reposting, or engaging with material that demeans, mocks, or exploits vulnerable individuals.
The council stressed that digital platforms should not become breeding grounds for stigma and discrimination, reiterating its commitment to defending the rights and dignity of persons with disabilities.
Mayor Niña Jose-Quiambao
Nina Jose-Quiambao, the mayor of Bayambang, Pangasinan, who recently went viral, expressed her support for Josh, praising his character and faith.
“Kuya Josh is one of the sweetest beings in the planet,” she wrote. “He is so prayerful to our Blessed Mother.”
“I stand by Kuya Josh,” she added, ending her post with the hashtag #bulliessuck.
Rep. Carlos Loria
House Special Committee on Persons with Disabilities chairperson Rep. Carlos Andes Loria also strongly condemned the remarks, saying the harm caused by mocking a person's disability extends beyond the individual targeted.
“There is nothing amusing about humiliating another human being. Words spoken for a moment of laughter can leave wounds long after the laughter has stopped,” Loria said.
“When a person's disability becomes the subject of mockery, the hurt reaches beyond that individual. It reaches persons with disabilities who have endured similar cruelty, and families who worry whether their loved ones will be met with kindness or contempt,” he added.
Loria expressed solidarity with Josh, his family, and other persons with disabilities whose dignity has been diminished by discriminatory attitudes.
“No one should have to prove their worth to be treated with respect. No person's disability should ever be turned into someone else's entertainment,” he said.
He emphasized that persons with disabilities have their own voices, aspirations, relationships, and contributions to their communities, adding that their dignity does not depend on their abilities, achievements, family names, or whether others understand them.
Loria also cited Sections 39 to 42 of Republic Act No. 7277, as amended by Republic Act No. 9442, which define and prohibit public ridicule and vilification of persons with disabilities.
He said freedom of expression comes with responsibility, particularly for content creators whose platforms can influence how audiences think and behave.
“Humor can bring people together. It should never teach an audience that another person's humiliation is acceptable,” Loria said.
While acknowledging the apologies issued by the hosts and those behind the program, the lawmaker stressed that apologies should be accompanied by concrete efforts to understand the harm caused and prevent similar incidents.
He recommended listening to persons with disabilities, undertaking disability sensitivity training, and adopting clear standards against discriminatory content as meaningful steps toward accountability.
“The measure of an apology is the change that follows it,” he said.
Loria also urged authorities to fairly evaluate any complaints filed under existing laws, with full respect for due process and the rights of all concerned.
He reaffirmed his commitment to strengthening public awareness, advancing legislation, and working with persons with disabilities and their organizations to address discrimination and remove barriers to their participation in society.
“To Josh and his family: I stand with you. No hurtful remark can diminish Josh's worth or his right to be treated with dignity,” Loria said.
He also reminded Filipinos with disabilities who have experienced ridicule or exclusion that they deserve to have their voices heard and their rights upheld.
“Disability is never a reason for ridicule. Dignity is every person's right. Respect is everyone's responsibility,” he added.
Senator Erwin Tulfo
Senator Erwin Tulfo also condemned the derogatory remarks made against Josh on the podcast, stressing that disability should never be treated as a punchline.
In a statement, Tulfo, chairperson of the Senate Committee on Social Justice, Welfare, and Rural Development, denounced the podcast hosts for calling Josh, the eldest son of actress Kris Aquino, “walang kwenta (worthless).”
“Disability should never be made a punchline,” Tulfo said in Filipino, emphasizing that persons with disabilities (PWDs) deserve respect and should not be subjected to discrimination.
“It is ironic that those without disabilities are the ones who seem to lack understanding and sensitivity toward the struggles of persons with disabilities,” he added.
Tulfo also questioned the extent of discrimination experienced by ordinary Filipinos with disabilities, noting that the incident involved someone from a prominent family.
“If this can happen to PWDs from well-known families, how much more discrimination might ordinary Filipinos with disabilities experience?” he said.
“Having a disability is not a person’s fault, and there should be no room for discrimination against our fellow Filipinos with disabilities."
While acknowledging the country's progress in protecting the rights of persons with disabilities, Tulfo said the incident showed that more work was needed to ensure their dignity and inclusion.
He vowed to continue supporting policies aimed at improving the welfare of PWDs, including Senate Bill No. 1405, which seeks to grant lifetime validity to PWD identification cards for individuals with permanent disabilities.
Tulfo also cited Senate Bill No. 1830, which seeks to improve accessibility for PWDs at tourism sites.
“Our efforts do not end with condemnation. We will continue to fight for better rights and protection for persons with disabilities in the country,” he said.
Senator Joel Villanueva
Senator Joel Villanueva called on content creators and digital platforms to take responsibility for content that mocks PWDs.
In a statement, Villanueva described the remarks as offensive and unacceptable, stressing that disability, including autism, should never be a source of entertainment.
“As a parent, it is deeply painful to hear a child with a disability being ridiculed. No matter how we look at the situation, no form of disability, including autism, should ever be treated as a joke,” Villanueva said in Filipino.
He also criticized the podcast hosts, saying their remarks did not make them more masculine or impressive.
The senator emphasized that the issue went beyond Josh, highlighting how some people continue to treat disability as a punchline.
“A nation cannot call itself inclusive while its loudest voices treat disability as entertainment,” he said.
Villanueva also called on content creators and podcasters to recognize their influence and the responsibility that comes with it, warning that mocking a person's disability could encourage audiences to adopt similar behavior.
He urged production companies and networks to establish clear content standards before programs are aired, stressing that deleting an episode only after public backlash was not enough.
Villanueva likewise called on digital platforms to take action against content that demeans persons with disabilities, saying they have a responsibility to help make online spaces safe and inclusive.
The senator expressed support for parents, siblings, and caregivers who work to create a more accepting environment for their loved ones, saying they should not have to see their experiences and struggles ridiculed for online views.
"Finally, we remind digital platforms that they are not mere bystanders. Those who shape the digital environment must also take responsibility for making it safe. We urge platforms to take action against content that demeans persons with disabilities, just as we expect them to protect children online," he said.
Former Senator Koko Pimentel
Former Senate President Aquilino “Koko” Pimentel likewise condemned the hosts' remarks, stressing that humiliating someone because of a disability should never be considered entertainment.
“Calling someone ‘worthless’ and making fun of his condition is not comedy. It is cruelty. No person, especially someone with a disability, deserves to be treated that way,” Pimentel said.
He emphasized that having a disability does not diminish a person's worth and that everyone deserves dignity and respect.
“Having a disability does not mean a person has no value. Every person has value. Every person deserves respect,” he said in Filipino.
Pimentel, who championed PWD rights and inclusive policies during his Senate tenure, said respect for persons with disabilities must extend beyond legislation to everyday interactions and content shared online.
He cited Republic Act No. 9442, which amended the Magna Carta for Persons with Disabilities and prohibits public ridicule and vilification of PWDs.
“There is a place for humor, but a person's disability should never be made the subject of ridicule,” Pimentel said.
The former Senate president acknowledged the podcast hosts' public apology but stressed that it must be accompanied by genuine reflection and a commitment to change.
“An apology is a start, but it should come with genuine reflection and a commitment not to repeat the same behavior. Content creators must understand that their words have consequences, especially when they reinforce prejudice against persons with disabilities,” he said.
Pimentel called for more understanding and inclusion, emphasizing that PWDs deserve equal opportunities, protection from discrimination, and respect.
The controversy stemmed from a now-deleted “Machong Chismisan” episode titled “Ang Pagbabalik Ni Kris Aquino,” in which the hosts mocked Josh by comparing him with his younger brother, Bimby, and making remarks about his disability.
Following the backlash, the podcast took down the October 5 episode and apologized to those offended, the PWD community, and the people mentioned.