ADHD or bipolar disorder? Why the two are often confused, according to a psychiatrist
Did you know that ADHD and bipolar disorder can look similar and therefore can be tricky to diagnose?
लेखक JADE VERONIQUE YAP,GMA News··18K पढ़े गए
ADHD or bipolar disorder? Why the two are often confused, according to a psychiatrist
Did you know that ADHD and bipolar disorder can look similar and therefore can be tricky to diagnose?
According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is one of the most common neurodevelopmental disorders of childhood. It is characterized by persistent symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity.
Meanwhile, the World Health Organization (WHO) defines bipolar disorder as a mental health condition that affects a person’s mood, energy, activity levels, and ability to function. It is characterized by episodes of mania (extreme high) or hypomania (milder than mania) and episodes of depression.
In an interview with GMA News Online, psychiatrist Dr. Rowald Alibudbud shared that one reason ADHD and bipolar disorder are sometimes confused with each other is that they can look similar on the surface, particularly in their visible behaviors.
“For example, both can involve talkativeness, having lots of energy, acting impulsively, difficulty concentrating, restlessness, and having social problems at work, school, or in relationships. However, the underlying reason for these symptoms is usually different,” Alibudbud said.
In ADHD, these traits tend to be relatively consistent over time.
“For example, ADHD starts in childhood and can be consistent since then. The person may have struggled with attention, organization, impulsivity, or hyperactivity since childhood, even if they were never formally diagnosed,” he said.
In bipolar disorder, symptoms typically occur in distinct episodes. Hypomanic episodes generally last at least four days, while manic episodes typically last at least one week.
A person may experience periods of relatively typical functioning between episodes, followed by distinct changes in mood, such as depression or mania/hypomania. During these episodes, their mood, energy, sleep, and behavior may noticeably differ from their usual patterns.
“A useful analogy is that ADHD is often more like a person’s baseline operating system, while bipolar disorder involves significant shifts or episodes that come and go,” he said.
Beyond ADHD and bipolar disorders, there are also several other mental health conditions that can resemble them.
These includes anxiety disorders, autism spectrum disorder (ASD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), trauma-related conditions such as PTSD, and personality disorders, particularly borderline personality disorder.
However, not all symptoms associated with mental health disorders necessarily mean that a person has a specific mental health condition. Alibudbud emphasized that similar symptoms may also be caused by the use of illegal substances.
“Someone who is chronically sleep deprived, highly anxious, experiencing trauma, or using stimulants, including illegal substances like methamphetamine, commonly known as shabu, or MDMA, known as ecstasy may also appear restless, distracted, impulsive, or emotionally reactive,” he shared.
“This is why diagnosis requires looking beyond individual symptoms and understanding the whole story of a person's life, development, and functioning over time,” he said.
Knowing the symptoms
When diagnosing bipolar disorder, Alibudbud said doctors do not simply look for day-to-day or hour-to-hour mood swings “since everyone experiences mood changes.”
“Bipolar disorder involves specific patterns and episodes that are significantly different from a person's usual state,” he said.
Aside from episodes of mania or hypomania that typically last for several days, psychiatrists also look for sustained increases in energy and activity.
A person may suddenly take on numerous projects, start businesses, spend excessively, become unusually sociable, or engage in activities at a level that is noticeably out of character.
“This is often one of the most important clues. The person may also have a reduced need for sleep. This is different from simply staying up late, since it often involves a person who may sleep only a few hours yet still feel fully energized rather than tired,” he noted.
“Many patients also describe their minds as moving very quickly, jumping from one idea to another. Speech may also become rapid, difficult to interrupt, or more pressured than usual,” Alibudbud added.
Some individuals also develop an “exaggerated sense of confidence, importance, or capability,” or increased risk-taking behaviors such as excessive spending, reckless driving, risky sexual behavior, impulsive business decisions, and even increased gambling.
“When we see these behaviors and mood changes, the question is not simply, does this person have changes in mood, energy, or impulsivity in the past few minutes? The question is usually, has there been a clear and significant change from their usual self that occurs in recognizable episodes lasting for several days?" he shared.
Late diagnosis is common among women, particularly those with ADHD and, in some cases, bipolar disorder, according to the expert.
“Historically, much of the research and many diagnostic frameworks were based on male presentations of these conditions,” Alibudbud said.
ADHD symptoms, for instance, may be less noticeable in girls, who can present with inattentiveness, daydreaming, disorganization, or feeling overwhelmed rather than the hyperactivity or disruptive behavior more commonly associated with boys.
As a result, some may go undiagnosed until adulthood, when increased demands from college, work, or parenting make difficulties with attention and organization more apparent.
Women with bipolar disorder may also experience delays in diagnosis, particularly when depressive episodes are more prominent. Some may initially be diagnosed with depression before the pattern of manic or hypomanic episodes becomes clear.
The expert also noted that the rising number of mental health diagnoses in recent years should not automatically be interpreted as overdiagnosis.
Greater mental health awareness, reduced stigma, increased access to mental health professionals, and improved understanding of how conditions manifest across different genders and age groups may have helped identify people who were previously overlooked.
“We might not necessarily be seeing entirely new conditions emerge. But we are becoming better at recognizing people who were previously overlooked,” the expert said.
He stressed that increased awareness should be accompanied by proper clinical assessment, noting that diagnosis should not be based solely on social media trends or self-labeling.
“The goal of assessment and evaluation should not be solely about diagnostic labeling, but rather about accurately understanding people so they can receive support, treatment, and accommodations tailored to their needs, not their diagnostic labels.” —JCB GMA News
The Philippines has several mental health hotlines and services. These include: DOH-NCMH Hotline: 0917-899-8727 and 02-7989-8727; Natasha Goulbourn Foundation Hopeline: 0917-558-4673, 0918-873-4673, and 02-8804-4673; and In Touch Crisis Line: 0917-800-1123, 0922-893-8944, and 02-8893-7603.