Fitbit Air vs WHOOP: What's Google Bringing to the Wrist?
Google recently introduced the Fitbit Air in India, priced at ₹13,999. It’s a lightweight fitness tracker that monitors your health, sleep and daily activity without a screen.
Ni Anjan N Ghosh··12K nabasa
Fitbit Air vs WHOOP: What's Google Bringing to the Wrist?
Google recently introduced the Fitbit Air in India, priced at ₹13,999. It’s a lightweight fitness tracker that monitors your health, sleep and daily activity without a screen.
Now, if you’re wondering what’s so special about a fitness tracker without a display, you’re asking the right question.
WHOOP has been doing this for years.
In fact, WHOOP has built quite a reputation around the idea that you don’t need another screen on your wrist to understand what’s happening with your body.
So, Google certainly hasn’t invented anything new here. But it is approaching the idea a little differently.
The difference isn’t really the hardware
Both Fitbit Air and WHOOP are designed to be worn throughout the day and night, quietly collecting information about your activity, heart rate, sleep and recovery.
Neither interrupts you with WhatsApp messages nor reminds you that someone has liked your photograph.
You check the information on your phone whenever you want.
WHOOP has traditionally focused on people who take their training and recovery seriously. Its strength lies in helping users understand how much strain they’re putting on their bodies, whether they’re recovering properly and how their sleep affects their performance.
Fitbit Air appears to be aimed at a broader audience.
Someone who wants to understand their daily activity, improve their sleep or develop healthier routines, without necessarily training for a marathon.
And Google is putting considerable emphasis on its Gemini-powered Health Coach.
Rather than simply presenting charts and numbers, the idea is to help users understand what the information means and what they might do differently.
For example, it could suggest adjustments to your fitness routine or help you understand whether you’re getting enough rest.
Of course, WHOOP already provides detailed coaching and recommendations, so Google isn’t entering unexplored territory.
The question is whether Gemini can make those insights easier for ordinary users to understand and act upon.
That’s something I’d want to see tested properly before declaring a winner.
Now comes the subscription question
This is where the two approaches become interesting.
With WHOOP, you’re essentially buying into a membership. The wearable and access to its tracking and analysis features are tied to that subscription.
Google, on the other hand, sells Fitbit Air as a device you can purchase outright.
Basic health and activity tracking is available without a continuing subscription. But if you want the more advanced Gemini-powered coaching, you’ll need Google Health Premium.
Google includes a three-month trial, after which the subscription becomes an additional expense if you decide to continue.
So, it’s not quite a case of Google offering everything without a subscription.
And at ₹13,999, the Fitbit Air isn’t particularly cheap either.
There are plenty of fitness bands in India that cost considerably less and even include a display.
But those aren’t necessarily offering the same kind of health analysis or coaching.
I’d be interested in comparing what users actually get for their money over two or three years, rather than looking only at the initial purchase price.
Google Fitbit Air
WHOOP 5.0
Screen
None
None
Main audience
Everyday fitness and wellness users
Fitness enthusiasts focused on recovery and performance
Main audience
Buy the device outright
Membership-based
Health insights
Google Health app and Gemini-powered coaching
Recovery, strain, sleep and training insights
Subscription
Optional for basic tracking; required for AI coaching
Required
Battery
Up to 7 days
Up to 14 days
India pricing
₹13,999
Depends on membership tier
Do we really need another fitness tracker?
This is where the subject gets interesting.
Most of us already have smartphones, and many of us wear smartwatches that monitor our steps, heart rate, sleep and exercise.
So why would someone buy a separate device that does many of the same things?
For some people, the answer could simply be comfort.
A lightweight band without a screen may be easier to wear while sleeping or exercising. And not having another display constantly demanding attention is certainly appealing.
But I think the real value lies in what you do with the information.
If a tracker tells me that I slept badly, that’s useful. If it helps me understand why and suggests something practical, I can change, that’s better.
On the other hand, if I spend every morning studying charts about my sleep instead of actually getting enough sleep, I may have missed the point entirely.
Fitbit Air is an interesting addition to this category, particularly because Google has the software and AI resources to develop its health platform further.
But I wouldn’t rush to recommend it over WHOOP without comparing the accuracy of their measurements, the quality of their recommendations and the long-term subscription costs.
For now, I’d say Google is making screenless fitness tracking more accessible to people who may not consider themselves serious athletes.
Whether its AI coaching is good enough to make Fitbit Air stand out is something we’ll have to find out.
GadgetBaaz Take: WHOOP already proved we don’t need a screen to track our fitness. Now Google wants to prove we don’t need an expensive subscription either. Unless, of course, we want the AI coach!