NSE Explains 200-Point Nifty Spike During Closing Auction, Says No 'Sudden Jump' in Index
The National Stock Exchange (NSE) has issued a late-night detailed clarification after confusion erupted on Monday over a more than 200-point jump in the Nifty 50’s discovered closing price following the first day of the
Ni Mohammad Haris··40K nabasa
NSE Explains 200-Point Nifty Spike During Closing Auction, Says No 'Sudden Jump' in Index
The National Stock Exchange (NSE) has issued a late-night detailed clarification after confusion erupted on Monday over a more than 200-point jump in the Nifty 50’s discovered closing price following the first day of the Closing Auction Session (CAS).
The sharp difference between the Nifty’s 3:15 pm level and its discovered closing value led many traders to question whether the market had suddenly surged in the last few minutes of trade. However, the exchange said there was no sudden movement in the index and the apparent spike was a result of how the newly introduced closing auction mechanism works.
Why did the confusion arise?
On August 3, the Nifty 50 ended regular trading around 24,573 at 3:15 pm. However, the official discovered closing price was around 24,774, creating the impression that the index had rallied over 200 points in the final minutes.
This also triggered confusion among derivatives traders as option premiums did not immediately reflect the discovered closing price during regular market hours. The clarification came after social media was flooded with posts questioning the unusual gap between the last traded index level and the official closing value.
What did NSE say?
NSE said investors should interpret the index chart during the Closing Auction Session differently. “There is no sudden change in the Index at 3:30 pm but the order collection, cancellation and matching follows a process and as there is no continuous order matching between 3:15 pm and 3:30 pm, the index value is constant as it is based on traded values,” it added.
The exchange added that indicative values, calculated continuously using equilibrium prices during the auction period, are displayed separately on the exchange website.
How does the Closing Auction Session work?
The Closing Auction Session has been introduced under Sebi’s guidance to improve transparency and ensure fair and robust price discovery. It is currently being implemented in phases.
From August 3, the new system applies only to cash market stocks that have derivatives (F&O) contracts. All other stocks continue to use the earlier VWAP-based closing price mechanism.
The CAS runs from 3:15 pm to 3:35 pm and consists of different stages:
3:15 pm-3:20 pm: Reference price calculation and transition from normal trading.
3:20 pm-3:25 pm: Order entry for both market and limit orders.
3:25 pm-3:30 pm: Only limit orders can be entered. Market orders cannot be modified or cancelled.
The order book closes randomly between 3:28 pm and 3:30 pm, after which matching takes place.
Meanwhile, the equity derivatives segment continues trading until 3:40 pm.
How is the closing price determined?
Unlike continuous trading, the closing price is not based on the last traded price. Instead, it is determined using the equilibrium price mechanism, which identifies the price at which the maximum quantity of shares can be traded.
NSE said, “The closing price in CAS is determined based on the equilibrium price mechanism. The equilibrium price is the price at which the maximum volume is executable. Market orders are given priority over limit orders.”
The reference price for the auction is based on the VWAP of trades executed between 3:00 pm and 3:15 pm. If there are no trades during this period, the day’s last traded price becomes the reference price. A price band of ±3% applies during the auction.
Why can the closing price differ sharply?
The NSE explained that the auction uses a separate order book from the normal trading session. Since prices are discovered independently during the auction, closing prices of individual stocks may differ from their 3:15 pm traded prices. As the Nifty is calculated using these individual stock prices, the index closing value can also differ significantly.
The exchange noted that similar price differences have long been observed during the pre-open session.
“Both the Exchanges have separate order books for CAS session similar to the continuous trading session and hence, the prices of the individual stocks are also different. As the index is calculated based on the prices determined of the individual stocks, the index values can also be different.”
Strong participation on Day 1
According to NSE, the first day of the Closing Auction Session saw encouraging participation. A total of 515 trading members placed orders for 56,773 unique PANs, compared with 403 trading members and 42,822 unique PANs during the day’s pre-open session.
“It may be noted that Pre-open session has been implemented more than a decade ago. So given the first day, the participation levels were very good. This is expected to mature and increase with time,” the exchange said.