Instead Of Cutting People Off, Clinical Psychologist Suggests Downgrading A Difficult Relationship
Toxic, traumatising and unsportive – these are some words that people use very liberally on social media nowadays. And these strongly defined words are used to describe people who may be on your same wavelength, have ser
Ni Abigail Banerji··7K nabasa
Instead Of Cutting People Off, Clinical Psychologist Suggests Downgrading A Difficult Relationship
Toxic, traumatising and unsportive – these are some words that people use very liberally on social media nowadays. And these strongly defined words are used to describe people who may be on your same wavelength, have served the purpose they came into your life for, or you might’ve grown apart from. This doesn’t mean that you need to have a big fight with these people in your life or need to make a dramatic exit from the relationship.
Not every difficult relationship needs to end, and not every relationship needs to become closer. Sometimes, the healthiest thing to do is to accept a person for who they are and change the role they play in your life.
This is the idea shared by James Ellis, an influencer and clinical psychologist, in an Instagram reel that offers a different perspective on navigating complicated relationships. Instead of viewing relationships in black-and-white terms — either staying close or cutting someone off — Ellis suggests there is another option: downgrading the relationship to a level that works for both people.
“Some of you don’t need to end the relationship; you need to downgrade it, and I mean that seriously,” he says in the reel.
The advice can apply to romantic relationships, friendships and family bonds. Sometimes, a person you care about may not be capable of offering the emotional support, understanding or intimacy you need. That does not necessarily mean the relationship has to disappear from your life.
View this post on Instagram
A post shared by James Ellis PhD – “The Loneliness Doctor” (@lonelinessdoctor)
Not Every Relationship Has To Be All Or Nothing
One of the biggest mistakes people make when navigating relationships, Ellis suggests, is believing they have only two choices: remain close to someone or cut them off completely.
“One of the biggest mistakes I think we’re making with our relationships right now is believing that we only have two options, staying close or cutting someone off,” he says.
He argues that relationships can be reorganised instead of ended. For instance, a close friendship may not develop into the emotionally supportive bond you had hoped for. A sibling may never offer the emotional intimacy you want, while certain conversations with a parent may repeatedly lead to conflict.
Recognising these limitations can be painful, especially when the relationship matters to you. However, accepting that someone cannot meet all your emotional needs does not mean you have to stop caring about them.
“And trust me, I know that there can be real grief in accepting these things. But accepting the other person’s limitations doesn’t have to end the relationship. You can instead downgrade it,” Ellis says.
What Does It Mean To Downgrade A Relationship?
Downgrading a relationship does not necessarily mean becoming hostile, holding a grudge or pretending the other person no longer matters. Instead, it involves changing your expectations and the amount of access someone has to your time, energy and emotional life.
Ellis offers a few examples of what this might look like in practice.
“Maybe that means you just see them less often. Maybe instead of spending an entire weekend together, you meet for lunch,” he says.
In a friendship, this could mean meeting occasionally for an activity you both enjoy instead of relying on the person for emotional support. In a romantic relationship, it could involve reassessing whether the relationship can meet both partners’ needs and whether different expectations or boundaries are realistic. In a family relationship, it might mean avoiding certain subjects that repeatedly lead to arguments.
Ellis explains that people can continue enjoying the parts of a relationship that work without expecting every aspect of it to fulfil them.
“Or maybe you stop going to this person for emotional support, but you can still enjoy going to a baseball game together. Or maybe there are a few subjects you just respectfully decide are simply off limits,” he says.
The idea is not to ignore problems or accept hurtful behaviour indefinitely. It is to recognise what a relationship can realistically offer and decide how much space it should occupy in your life.
Setting Boundaries Does Not Always Mean Cutting Someone Off
The concept also offers a different way of thinking about boundaries. Setting a boundary is often associated with distancing yourself from someone, but it can also mean changing how you interact with them.
For example, you might choose to share less personal information with a friend who repeatedly dismisses your feelings. You might limit visits with a relative if extended time together tends to result in conflict. Or you might stop expecting a partner to fulfil a particular emotional need if repeated conversations have made it clear that the relationship cannot provide what you are looking for.
The key is to make these decisions consciously rather than repeatedly putting yourself in situations that leave you feeling disappointed or emotionally drained.
As Ellis puts it, “You’re not pretending that problems don’t exist. You’re just changing the conditions of the relationship so that the parts that do work have a chance to survive.”
However, this approach is not appropriate for every situation. Relationships involving abuse, coercion, threats or persistent harm may require stronger boundaries, distance or ending contact altogether. Preserving a connection should never come at the cost of personal safety or wellbeing.
Accepting A Relationship For What It Is
Perhaps the most significant part of Ellis’ message is the reminder that relationships do not always develop the way we expect them to. A friend may not become the person we turn to in a crisis. A family member may never understand our choices. A romantic relationship may not offer the kind of closeness we once imagined.
There can be genuine sadness in letting go of these expectations, particularly when they involve people we love. But accepting the reality of a relationship can also help us decide how to move forward without repeatedly trying to make it into something it cannot be.
“And I think that’s a really important part of social health that we just are not talking about enough,” Ellis says, adding that a fulfilling, connected life does not require every relationship to become closer.
“Because part of having a rich, connected life is accepting that not every relationship is gonna become what we hoped it would be. And not every relationship needs to become closer, and not every difficult relationship needs to disappear.”
His final message is a reminder that the choice is not always between holding on to a relationship exactly as it is and walking away from it entirely.
“Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is accept the relationship for what it can be, limitations and all, instead of ending it because it couldn’t become what you wanted it to be.”