Ramayana: AR Rahman Breaks Silence On Mangal Rang Criticism, Says ‘You Can’t Satisfy Everyone’
AR Rahman has addressed the criticism surrounding Mangal Rang, one of the songs from Nitesh Tiwari’s upcoming Ramayana: Rise of a Legend. The composer, who is creating the film’s music alongside Hans Zimmer, said he rema
Ni Yatamanyu Narain··128K nabasa
Ramayana: AR Rahman Breaks Silence On Mangal Rang Criticism, Says ‘You Can’t Satisfy Everyone’
AR Rahman has addressed the criticism surrounding Mangal Rang, one of the songs from Nitesh Tiwari’s upcoming Ramayana: Rise of a Legend. The composer, who is creating the film’s music alongside Hans Zimmer, said he remains his own first critic and does not expect every musical decision to find immediate acceptance.
The song had divided listeners after its release, particularly over what some described as a qawwali-like treatment for a composition linked to the mythological epic. Rahman, however, said music for a project of this scale is not arrived at hurriedly, with certain ideas being allowed to sit for months before the team takes a final call.
AR Rahman Says He Is His ‘First Critic’
Speaking to The Indian Express, Rahman rejected the idea that he instinctively approves everything he composes.
“I am my first critic. It is not that I just love everything I do,” he said.
According to Rahman, compositions sometimes need time before their strengths become apparent. He compared the process to pickle, where ageing can actually improve the final result.
“Sometimes you need to take anthropology into consideration. Sometimes, you let something be, like pickle: for certain tunes, the older it is, the better it becomes,” he said.
Rahman also acknowledged that not every listener will immediately understand why a particular musical route has been chosen. At some point, he said, a composer has to stop allowing every reaction to dictate the work.
Quoting Apple co-founder Steve Jobs, Rahman added, “If you want to satisfy everyone, go sell ice cream.”
What Went Into Mangal Rang
Mangal Rang features the principal Ramayana characters played by Ranbir Kapoor, Sai Pallavi and Yash.
The song attracted criticism online after listeners questioned its musical treatment, but the composition itself draws from multiple classical influences.
Rahman used the shuddh notes of Bilawal while incorporating elements of Maand, a raga associated with bhajans and wedding music, along with touches of Pahadi.
The attempt was to arrive at a sound that could sit within devotional and traditional musical spaces without simply reproducing an older template.
Despite the debate surrounding it, Mangal Rang later reached the No. 1 position on YouTube’s trending music chart during the week of its release.
AR Rahman On Working With Hans Zimmer
Rahman’s collaboration with Hans Zimmer has been another major talking point around the film.
Zimmer, whose credits include Interstellar, Inception and Gladiator, joins Rahman on a project that has songs, background score and multiple versions being prepared across languages and markets.
Rahman said Zimmer’s association could also introduce the story to audiences who may otherwise not have followed the project as closely.
“His name coming in Ramayana would bring a whole set of new audience curiosity,” Rahman said.
He also spoke about the sheer volume of work involved in the film.
“The film has a score and it has songs and it has probably like 10 movies worth of work, where there were five different languages and two different versions: the Hollywood version and the Indian version and also the kind of pressure the whole team had for every note, every tune.”
Rahman said the scrutiny around each musical choice reflected how much was riding on the film.
“That is when one understands that there’s so much at stake for them that they want to be really sure,” he added.
He also said that watching audiences from different parts of the country respond to the music had been encouraging.
What We Know About Ramayana: Rise Of A Legend
Directed by Nitesh Tiwari, Ramayana: Rise of a Legend features Ranbir Kapoor as Lord Ram and Sai Pallavi as Sita, while Yash plays Ravana.
Ravie Dubey will be seen as Lakshman and Sunny Deol as Hanuman. The ensemble also includes Rakul Preet Singh as Surpanakha, Lara Dutta as Kaikeyi, Kajal Aggarwal as Mandodari, along with Arun Govil, Vivek Oberoi and Sheeba Chaddha in pivotal roles.
The film has reportedly been mounted on a budget of around Rs 4,000 crore.
The first instalment is scheduled to arrive in theatres on November 5 in Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada and Malayalam.
With Rahman and Zimmer sharing musical duties, every release from the soundtrack has inevitably come under close attention. Rahman, however, appears comfortable with that scrutiny, even if he does not necessarily agree with every reaction.
As he put it himself, trying to satisfy everybody is simply not the job.