'What A Scam': Photographer's 16-Year-Old @X Username Was Taken After Twitter Rebranding; Old Post Goes Viral Again
A 2023 controversy involving Elon Musk and a photographer’s Twitter username has resurfaced online, drawing fresh attention to the circumstances surrounding the platform’s rebranding as X. The incident centres on Gene X.
Por Sakshi Arora··68K lecturas
'What A Scam': Photographer's 16-Year-Old @X Username Was Taken After Twitter Rebranding; Old Post Goes Viral Again
A 2023 controversy involving Elon Musk and a photographer’s Twitter username has resurfaced online, drawing fresh attention to the circumstances surrounding the platform’s rebranding as X. The incident centres on Gene X. Hwang, a San Francisco-based photographer who reportedly lost access to his long-held @x handle after the company took over the username.
Hwang, who co-founded Orange Photography, had registered the @x username in 2007 and retained it for 16 years. Over time, the account reportedly amassed around 53,000 followers and attracted several purchase offers, with some reaching as high as $40,000. However, Hwang allegedly declined to part with the handle.
According to the post, Hwang had even faced an account-related security issue in 2014, when hackers allegedly gained access to his X account. Twitter reportedly helped him recover the username at the time.
How Gene Hwang Lost His @x Username
The situation reportedly changed in July 2023, when Musk announced that Twitter would be rebranded as X. While Hwang was in Canada participating in a pinball tournament, the platform was preparing to take over the @x username.
On July 25, 2023, when the rebranding officially took place, Hwang allegedly received an email from Twitter support informing him that his username was affiliated with X Corp. His original handle was subsequently taken away, and he was assigned a lengthy alternative username, @x12345678998765.
The post further claimed that the company did not offer Hwang any monetary compensation for losing a username he had held for more than a decade. Instead, he was reportedly offered company merchandise, an exclusive tour of X’s headquarters and an opportunity to meet members of the management team.
Hwang allegedly even asked whether he could take home the old blue Twitter bird sign that was being removed from the company’s headquarters. However, his request was reportedly declined.
X’s Handle Marketplace Sparks Debate
The resurfaced post also drew attention to X’s Handle Marketplace, which reportedly launched in October 2025. The feature allows users to access rare and sought-after usernames, with prices ranging from $2,500 to more than $1 million, depending on the handle.
According to the post, users are required to maintain a paid subscription to retain access to certain handles, with the possibility of losing them if their subscription lapses.
Drawing a comparison between the two developments, the post questioned the platform’s approach to rare usernames, pointing out that the same company that allegedly took Hwang’s @x handle without monetary compensation now offers rare usernames through a paid marketplace.
The post concluded by highlighting that Hwang had spent 16 years building an identity around the username, rejected offers reportedly worth up to $40,000 and ultimately received only an offer of merchandise and an office tour.
Internet Reacts
The post quickly gained traction, prompting users to debate whether Hwang was entitled to compensation and whether he should have accepted the earlier offers to sell his username.
Elon Musk took a $40,000 username from a guy who had owned it for 16 years.
He paid him absolutely nothing.
Not even a dollar.
Instead, he was offered a T-shirt and a tour of Twitter’s headquarters.
This is the story of Gene X. Hwang the first @X username
2007
– photographer from San Francisco
– co-founder of Orange Photography
– registers @x on Twitter
– keeps the username for 16 years
over the years
account grows to ~53,000 followers
receives offers of up to $40,000 for the handle
But he refuses to sell
2014
– hackers steal his x account
– Twitter helps him recover it
July 23, 2023
– Elon Musk announces Twitter will become X
– Gene is in Canada playing in a pinball tournament
He has no idea what’s coming
July 25, 2023
– Twitter officially becomes X
– the company wants x
– Gene receives an email from Twitter support
“Your user handle is affiliated with X Corp.”
his username is taken and gets a new one @x12345678998765
what X offers him
– company merchandise
– exclusive tour of X headquarters
– meeting with the management team
$0.
Gene even asks if he can have the old blue Twitter bird sign being removed from headquarters.
they say no.
October 2025
X launches its Handle Marketplace
rare usernames can cost $2,500 to over $1 MILLION
users must maintain a paid subscription
lose the subscription, potentially lose the handle
the same company that took x without paying its owner now charges people for access to rare usernames.
16 years building an identity.
$40,000 in offers rejected.
and all he got was an offer of merchandise and an office tour.
BROTHER.
— StarPlatinum (@StarPlatinum_) November 2, 2026
“Under Twitter ToS, even before Elon bought the platform, users don’t own their handles, Twitter/X does. So they don’t technically owe him anything. That said, I do think Hwang should’ve gotten something more substantial given the circumstances. I hope they reconsider,” said one user.
Another person criticised Musk’s track record, saying, “I have never read a single story about Elon Musk doing something selfless and good. Not a single one,” while a third user shared a similar experience of losing a username.
“I lost my username Eminem to Spofity the same way. It stings. Funny thing is that there is still playlists on the Eminem account that I created,” the user commented.
Others were less sympathetic towards Hwang’s decision to turn down the reported offers. “He should’ve taken the $40K when he had the option. Idiot move,” one user remarked.
Another person summed up their reaction by saying, “Imagine turning down $40k for your handle and getting offered a tour of the building where they took it,” while another simply wrote, “What a scam.”
Disclaimer: This article is based on user-generated content. The claims made in the original post have not been independently verified by News18.