Employee Discovers Company Is Hiring For His Exact Role At A Higher Salary: 'My Hands Were Kind Of Shaking'
An accidental message from a recruiter has left an employee questioning his salary and sparked a debate online about workplace pay gaps. The senior data analyst discovered that his company was offering a salary starting
Por Sakshi Arora··17K lecturas
Employee Discovers Company Is Hiring For His Exact Role At A Higher Salary: 'My Hands Were Kind Of Shaking'
An accidental message from a recruiter has left an employee questioning his salary and sparked a debate online about workplace pay gaps. The senior data analyst discovered that his company was offering a salary starting 18K above his current pay for what appeared to be the exact same role he had held for two years.
The employee shared his experience in a post on Reddit’s r/remotejobsfinders subreddit titled, “A recruiter accidentally sent me the budget for my own role.” According to the post, a recruiter from an agency contacted him on LinkedIn about a fully remote senior data analyst position. He agreed to receive further details but was left stunned when the recruiter sent him a PDF containing the job description and salary budget.
The employee said he realised within seconds that the advertised position was identical to his own. The job description mentioned the same company, team and tools, along with his manager’s name as the hiring contact.
Having worked in the role for two years, he was surprised to discover that the company was apparently looking to hire another senior analyst without informing him.
However, the biggest revelation came when he checked the compensation details. The salary range mentioned in the document started at least 18K above what he currently earned.
The discovery left him shaken, particularly given the responsibilities he had taken on over the years. He explained that he trained new employees to use the company’s dashboards and had even handled his manager’s entire workload for six weeks during the previous winter. Despite these contributions, his last salary hike was just 4%.
Rather than immediately forwarding the document to HR, the employee decided to approach the situation carefully. After thinking about it for two days, he scheduled a meeting with his manager.
He did not disclose that he had received the PDF but explained that he had been researching market salaries. He then quoted a figure within the newly discovered salary range and expressed his desire to reach that level of compensation during the year.
According to the employee, his manager did not push back much and said he would “push for it”. While the employee remains uncertain about the outcome, he also responded to the recruiter, believing that another company might be willing to pay him what he was worth.
Reflecting on the situation, he admitted that part of him wanted to forward the document to HR without saying anything. However, he turned to Reddit to ask whether he had handled the situation correctly.
Internet Reacts
The post prompted several users to share their perspectives on salary negotiations, workplace transparency and the risks of staying with the same employer for too long.
One user argued that remaining in the same company for years could put employees at a disadvantage when it comes to salary growth. They wrote, “It is not a secret that staying more than a year in a company works against yourself. The maximum raise after a year (if you get one) is at best 5%. Inflation is 6-8% so you already loose purchase power by staying on the same role.
Companies cannot justify raising your salary more than that because they would need to raise the salary for everyone if the do it for 1 person. However they do not have to justify that for new employees so there you go. The best thing you can do is change jobs every so often and don’t get too comfy.”
Another Redditor advised the employee against immediately sharing the document with HR, suggesting that doing so might benefit the company more than the employee. The user recommended securing a positive performance review in writing and using the information during salary negotiations. They said, “If you forward to HR all that happens is the recruiter gets fired. You get nothing. Don’t let anyone know you have it. First, make sure you are not getting fired.
Try to get your manager to give you a positive “review” in writing. Second, use it to corner people verbally if you don’t get a raise above $18k… “Boss, just want to get paid the fair rate for my position and experience.
If we were hiring for this position today, what would the range be? Now add my experience?” If it is still below the range and you are in a protected class, talk to a labor attorney.”
A third user came up with a more unconventional suggestion, commenting, “Apply for the job under a clever version of your own name. Turn up to the interview.”
Another commenter shared an experience in which an employee discovered that her own position had been advertised without her knowledge. The user wrote, “My friend was at work one day and started getting calls asking about the job advertised. Yep it was her job. She asked to speak with the office manager and yep they were firing her. The audacity to advertise first though SMH.”
Someone else related the situation to their own workplace struggles, saying, “I’m covering for my boss for 3 months already and the company will be hiring my boss replacement that is $50K more above my salary range. lol I’m sad ugh.”
Meanwhile, another Redditor strongly opposed the idea of forwarding the document to HR, asking, “Forwarding it to HR would literally be the dumbest thing you could do. You have knowledge they’re unaware of so you shout it to everyone that you know???”
Disclaimer: This article is based on user-generated content. The claims made in the original post have not been independently verified by News18.